Choosing Irrigation Equipment: Pivot or Drip

Fit the system to field, crop and cash

KEARNEY, Nebraska — The best irrigation equipment is the kind that matches your field shape, soil, crop, water supply and budget. A center pivot suits large, fairly level fields in row crops. Drip suits high-value crops, odd-shaped fields and places where water is expensive or limited. Gravity and furrow systems still work on some farms. None of them wins everywhere, and a purchase made on the strength of a neighbor's enthusiasm can sit in your field for decades.

Here's how to compare options before you sign a purchase order.

Start with water, not equipment

How much water can you legally and physically use? Know your water rights or allocation, well capacity, pumping lift and seasonal limits. A pivot needs a certain flow to cover the acres under it, and a well that can't deliver will limit your system no matter how pretty it is. Your state water agency or natural resources district will explain permits, metering and any rules.

Then check energy. Pumping cost depends on lift and pressure, and a system that needs high pressure uses more power than one designed to run low. Ask your electric provider or fuel supplier about rates and about any irrigation programs.

Compare the main system types

Center pivots cover a circle, so corners of square fields are usually left out unless you add a corner system. They save labor, apply water uniformly when well maintained, and can use low-pressure nozzles to cut pumping costs. Lateral move systems fit rectangular fields but need more setup.

Drip delivers water at or near the root zone, keeps foliage dry and cuts evaporation loss, but needs filtration, regular flushing and careful management, since clogged emitters and rodent damage are real problems. It's common in vegetables, orchards and vineyards, and used in some row crop fields. Surface systems cost less to start but demand more labor and level ground. University of Nebraska CropWatch has research-based irrigation articles, and Nebraska Extension covers system types and management.

Ask hard questions of dealers

Get quotes from more than one dealer, and ask for an uniformity evaluation or a system design based on your sprinkler package, pressure and field profile. Ask what's included: pump, power unit, controls, installation, and electrical work. Ask about warranty, parts availability, and how service calls work during peak season, because a pivot that's down in the heat of summer is an expensive lawn ornament.

Ask for references of customers with similar soils and crops. Call them. Ask what they'd do differently.

Look at soil, slope and the crop

Soil type affects intake rate. Sandy soils take water fast but hold little; heavy soils hold plenty but can run off if applied too quickly. A pivot's end sprinklers can apply water faster than some soils absorb, which causes ponding and runoff. Your system design should match application rate to the soil.

The Web Soil Survey provides soil maps and descriptions for your fields. Combine that with your own observation, because a map doesn't know where the wet spot is. Slope matters too: uneven fields may need nozzle packages that handle pressure changes.

Check financing, cost-share and drought plans

Costs include the equipment, installation, pump, power and long-term maintenance. Talk to your lender early, and ask the Farm Service Agency about farm loans that may apply. The Natural Resources Conservation Service has offered cost-share for irrigation efficiency practices in some programs. Check what's open now, as programs, funds and rules change.

Also think about drought. Drought.gov offers current conditions and planning information, and it helps to know how your water source behaves in a dry spell before you depend on it.

Before you buy:

  1. Confirm water rights and well capacity.
  2. Pull soil maps and test intake.
  3. Get multiple quotes and a written design.
  4. Check dealer service history.
  5. Price the full operating cost, not only the purchase.

Irrigation is a long-term bet on water. Make sure it's a bet you can afford in a bad year, not just a good one.