How do I balance pasture and grain?
Let the grass set the grain
BOWLING GREEN, Kentucky — Balancing pasture and grain means figuring out how much dry matter your cows actually get from grass, then feeding just enough grain to cover what the grass can't. Too little grain and a high-producing cow loses condition and milk. Too much, and she eats less pasture, which is your cheapest feed, so you've paid for grain to replace grass.
The trick is that grass intake changes by the week, so the grain plan should too.
Estimate what the cows are getting from pasture
You can't see pasture intake directly, but you can estimate it. Look at pasture height before and after grazing, how many cows were in the paddock, and for how long. Many extension programs offer a grazing calculator, and a nutritionist can help you set up a way of estimating dry matter per cow.
Then check results: milk yield, body condition, and the fullness of the cows' left flank after grazing. If cows leave the paddock hungry and bawling, pasture intake is short.
Know what grain is for
Grain, mostly starch, provides energy that cool-season grass often lacks relative to its protein. A cow on lush grass can have plenty of protein and not enough fermentable energy. Adding a starch source helps the rumen microbes use the extra nitrogen, which can lift milk and cut waste. The more milk the cow gives, the more that gap matters.
For cows lower in production or later in lactation, grass alone may do fine.
Feed by group when you can
Cows early in lactation have the biggest gap and usually need the most grain. Late-lactation cows may need little. If you have a way to group cows, even a rough split of fresh and later cows, you can feed grain more precisely and avoid overfeeding the ones who don't need it.
In the parlor, many grazing dairies feed grain in set amounts per cow, adjusting it as pasture quality changes.
Watch the substitution effect
When you add grain, cows typically graze a little less. That's called substitution. It's why feeding a lot of grain on excellent pasture often brings smaller milk gains than you'd expect. When pasture is short or poor, the response to grain is bigger, since the grain fills a real gap instead of replacing grass.
This is a good reason to watch pasture quality. In a fast spring flush, you might cut grain. In a summer slump you may need more.
Protect the rumen
Large grain meals can cause acidosis, especially with lush, low-fiber pasture. Split grain into smaller feedings, avoid very finely ground feed, and make sure dry hay or other effective fiber is available when pasture is very lush. Watch manure: loose, bubbly manure and falling butterfat can signal trouble.
A weekly routine
- Measure pasture height or use a plate meter, and note growth rate.
- Estimate pasture dry matter per cow.
- Check milk volume and components, and body condition.
- Adjust grain by group up or down.
- Test pasture occasionally for protein and fiber.
- Review costs, including grain price against what the milk is worth.
Your feed supplier and nutritionist can help match grain type to your pasture. For milk and feed price context, Dairy Markets and Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker offer tools and information on dairy economics. For grazing guidance, see SARE and ATTRA.
If your cows are fat and the milk is flat, you might be overfeeding grain. If they're thin and running out of gas, you might be underfeeding it. Cows are good at telling you which. The hard part is paying attention.