What is the best way to make cottage cheese?

Cook the curd, rinse it, dress it

APPLETON, Wisconsin — Cottage cheese is small curd cooked in whey, drained, rinsed and mixed with cream. The best way to make it is to set skim milk with culture, a little rennet or acid, cut the curd, cook it slowly and rinse it so it's sweet and clean. Then you add a cream dressing for richness. It takes a few hours and attention to temperature. Here's how to do it, what to watch for and how to fix common issues, so your curds come out tender instead of rubbery.

Milk and setting

Skim milk gives the classic texture, and a cream dressing adds the fat later. Use pasteurized, not ultra-pasteurized, milk. Many recipes use a mesophilic culture and a small amount of rennet, set at around 72 to 86 degrees F for several hours. Others use direct acid like vinegar or citric acid with heat for a faster, simpler version.

Follow your recipe, since set time varies with culture and temperature. Cultured versions taste more like store-bought cottage cheese. Acid versions are quick and mild, but the curd is often a bit drier and squeakier.

Cut and cook

Once the curd is firm enough to cut cleanly, cut it into small cubes, about a half inch for small curd or larger for big curd. Let it rest, then heat slowly while stirring gently, raising the temperature around one or two degrees every few minutes toward the mid to high 110s degrees F, or as your recipe states.

The curd firms up and shrinks. If you cook too fast, the outside toughens and the center stays soft and rubbery. Stir gently and often, so pieces don't mat together. Test by squeezing a curd between your fingers. It should hold together and feel springy.

Drain and rinse

When curds are firm enough to squeak between your fingers, pour them into a cloth-lined colander. Rinse with cool water, then ice water if your recipe calls for it, stirring gently. This removes acid and whey, making the flavor mild and stopping further cooking. Rinse until the water runs clear.

Drain until no water drips. Some makers add a little salt. Lift the cloth and hold the curd to let the last of the water run off. Curd that stays wet will water down your dressing and spoil faster.

Add the dressing

Mix the curds with cream, or cream and milk, to taste. Add salt gradually. A cup of cream per pound of curd is a starting point for a rich cheese, but adjust to your own preference. Dry curd takes more dressing, and washed curd takes less.

Chill for an hour or two so flavors blend, and the curd soaks up some of the cream. Taste again before serving, and adjust salt. Dressing is where you make the cheese your own, and where different batches can be matched to the same taste.

Store and troubleshoot

Fresh cottage cheese lasts about a week in the fridge. Keep it cold and covered. If it smells sour or looks slimy, discard it. Don't leave the container out on the counter for long.

Rubbery curd comes from cooking too fast. Bitter flavor can come from too much rennet. Tough curd comes from overcooking. Mushy curd comes from undercooking or cutting too early. Keep a record of times and temperatures, and change one thing at a time.

For learning, see Penn State Extension, eXtension, Cornell Small Farms and AgMRC. Selling cottage cheese requires state dairy licensing, so check with your state regulator.

A few more details can help. Large-curd versions use bigger cubes and a shorter cook, and they feel looser on the tongue. Small-curd versions use smaller cubes and a longer cook, and they feel firmer. Either one benefits from a gentle hand when stirring, since broken curd turns the dressing cloudy. If you make this regularly, buy a thermometer that reads accurately in the 100 to 130 degree F range and check it against ice water first.

Cottage cheese is simple but fussy about heat. Go slow, and you'll get squeaky curd.