What is the best way to make Swiss cheese eyes?

Warm rooms and the right bacteria

ITHACA, New York — The holes in Swiss cheese, called eyes, are made by gas from bacteria. Specifically, propionic acid bacteria eat lactic acid in the cheese and release carbon dioxide, which collects in pockets. To get good eyes you need the right culture, a cheese with the right texture and a warm aging period. It's a delicate process, and even experienced makers get blind or cracked wheels. Here's what produces eyes, what ruins them and how to approach a first try without losing a whole summer's milk.

The culture that makes the holes

Swiss-style cheeses use a mix of thermophilic starter cultures, plus a propionic bacteria culture, often Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Both are sold by cheesemaking suppliers. Use the amounts the supplier recommends, since too much or too little affects results. The propionic culture is usually sold in tiny amounts, and it's easy to over- or under-dose without a precise scale or pre-measured packets.

Without the propionic culture, you can make an Alpine-style cheese, but you won't get typical Swiss holes. Store the culture as the supplier directs, usually cold or frozen, and use it before it expires. Old culture is a common reason for a wheel with no eyes at all.

Make a curd that can hold gas

Swiss curd is cut small, cooked to high temperatures and pressed under moderate weight. The finished cheese has to be elastic enough to stretch around gas bubbles without tearing. If the curd is too dry or brittle, gas escapes or cracks the wheel. If it's too wet and acidic, you can get lots of tiny holes or splits.

Brining follows pressing and controls salt and rind development. Too much salt can slow the propionic bacteria, so follow the brine time for your wheel size. Moisture and acid in the finished wheel are what decide whether the cheese can hold gas, so record your cut size, cook temperature and pressing schedule every time.

Run the warm room

After a cool aging period, wheels are moved to a warm room, often around 68 to 75 degrees F, for a few weeks. That's when propionic bacteria become active and eyes form. Watch the wheels. As gas builds, the sides bulge slightly, and thumping the wheel gives a hollow sound.

When eyes look developed, move wheels back to a cool space to slow activity. Leaving them warm too long creates overlarge eyes and splits. Turn wheels regularly and wipe the surface with brine to keep the rind in good shape. A thermometer and hygrometer in the warm room keep you from guessing.

Common problems

No eyes can mean low culture, too much salt or a curd that's too dry. Many small eyes can come from acid conditions or contamination. Cracks come from fast gas production or dry curd. A wheel that balloons early, before the warm room, points to unwanted gas-producing bacteria from poor milk quality or sanitation, which is a different problem from the one you're after.

Clean milk matters. Poor milk quality can cause unwanted gas bacteria and spoilage, and hay or dust in milk can influence eye formation. Good milking hygiene and clean storage are the first steps toward a Swiss wheel that looks the way you picture it.

Setting expectations

Even skilled makers don't get perfect eyes every time. Treat the first batches as learning. Keep a log of culture, temperature, salt and time, and compare notes as wheels age. You can sample a wheel with a cheese trier to check eyes and flavor before cutting it.

Read more at Penn State Extension, Cornell Small Farms, eXtension and AgMRC. Specialized cheesemaking suppliers offer technical sheets for their cultures. Selling Swiss-style cheese involves state licensing and, for raw milk, federal aging rules, so ask your state regulator early.

One practical idea is to start with a small wheel, a couple of pounds, so a failed warm room doesn't cost much. Another is to invest in a thermometer and hygrometer for the warm room before you buy anything else. Eye formation depends on steady conditions, and a room that swings by a few degrees can give you uneven results from one wheel to the next. Ask your Extension dairy specialist whether any licensed Swiss-style makers in your state offer tours.

Swiss cheese is a lot of work to put holes in something. Plan on eating the mistakes.