What is the best way to make yogurt cheese?

Strain it long, keep it simple

LOGAN, Utah — Yogurt cheese is plain yogurt with most of the whey strained out. That's it. The best way to make it is to start with good yogurt, strain it through a clean cloth in the fridge, and decide how thick you want it based on how long you let it hang. A few hours gives you thick, Greek-style yogurt. A day or so gives you spreadable cheese, and longer produces something firm enough to roll into balls. It's one of the cheapest and most forgiving cheeses around, and it's a good use for yogurt that's getting a little too tangy to eat with a spoon.

Start with the right yogurt

Plain, whole-milk yogurt with live cultures gives the creamiest cheese. Check the label and skip brands with added gelatin, starch or gums, since those can slow or block draining. Low-fat yogurt works, but the cheese turns out drier and more chalky, and nonfat yogurt gets close to rubbery.

If you make your own yogurt from farm milk, use a mild batch. Straining concentrates acidity, so yogurt that's already sour gets sharp fast. Fresh, mild yogurt a day or two old makes a better cheese than a jar that's been sitting at the back of the shelf.

Set up the straining rig

Line a sieve or colander with a double layer of butter muslin, fine cheesecloth or a clean flour-sack towel. Set it over a bowl deep enough to catch the whey without the sieve touching the liquid. Spoon in the yogurt, fold the cloth over the top, cover the bowl loosely and put the whole thing in the refrigerator.

Another approach is tying the cloth corners into a bag and hanging it from a cabinet knob or a wooden spoon laid across a pot. Either way, keep it cold. Yogurt left at room temperature during a long strain keeps fermenting and gets sour, and in a warm kitchen it can spoil.

Decide how long to strain

A few hours gets you thick yogurt. Six to twelve hours gives a cream-cheese texture. Twenty-four hours or more produces a firm, crumbly cheese you can roll in herbs. Weigh the yogurt at the start and the finished cheese at the end once, and you'll learn how much whey comes off, so you can plan batches and know what to expect.

Scrape the surface now and then if it forms a crust, but don't squeeze the bag hard. Squeezing pushes solids through the cloth and makes the cheese gritty.

Season and use it

Stir in salt to taste once straining is done. About a half teaspoon per pound is a common starting point, though your palate is the better judge. Add herbs, garlic, lemon zest or chopped peppers. For labneh-style serving, spread it on a plate and drizzle with olive oil.

Firm cheese can be rolled into balls and stored in oil in the fridge, but be careful. Homemade oil-packed products with garlic or fresh herbs can carry food safety risk if held too long or kept warm, so keep them chilled and eat them within a few days.

Use the whey and store the cheese

Save the whey for baking, smoothies, soaking grains or feeding to pigs or chickens in small amounts. Whey is acidic, so don't pour large volumes onto garden beds or lawn.

Keep finished yogurt cheese covered in the refrigerator and use it within about a week. If you see mold, off smells or pink streaks, discard it. For more help, try eXtension, Penn State Extension, and USDA AMS for dairy marketing information, plus AgMRC for ideas on selling value-added dairy products.

If you want more flavor variety, try a few small tests. Strain one jar for twelve hours and another for thirty-six, then taste them side by side with the same salt. Try cow-milk yogurt against goat-milk yogurt. Write down what you find. After three or four jars you'll know exactly which texture suits your kitchen, whether that's a spread for crackers, a base for dips or a firm ball for the market table.

It's the one cheese where doing less really is the whole technique. The cloth does the work while you do chores.