Which dairy equipment leases make sense?

Lease the fast-aging stuff, think twice on the rest

PLATTEVILLE, Wisconsin — Leases make the most sense for dairy equipment that changes quickly, is expensive to keep current or that you only need for a season, such as electronics, sensors, some feed and tractor equipment, or a trial run of a new technology. They make less sense for long-lived, custom-installed items like pipelines and bulk tanks, where owning usually costs less over the full life. Whether leasing wins for you depends on the actual terms, so compare it with a loan on paper before deciding.

Understand the lease types

Two basic forms show up. A fair market value (operating-style) lease has lower payments, and at the end you return the equipment, renew or buy it at its then-value. A fixed buyout or finance-style lease works more like a loan: payments are higher, and you buy the equipment for a set price at the end. Ask the lessor which one you're being offered and what happens at the end of term.

Tax and accounting treatment can differ depending on how the lease is structured. Check with your tax preparer and review IRS Publication 225 for farm tax basics.

Equipment that often suits leasing

Technology that might be obsolete in a few years is a better lease candidate than a stainless tank that will run for decades.

Equipment that usually favors owning

Pipelines, bulk tanks, vacuum pumps and parlor stalls are long-life assets. Leasing them can cost more over time, and custom installation means the lessor can't easily redeploy them. If you plan to keep equipment for most of its life, ownership generally pays off. But if cash is tight and the alternative is no upgrade at all, a lease might be a bridge. Run both numbers.

Read the fine print

Questions to ask before signing:

  1. What are the total payments over the term, including fees?
  2. Who pays for maintenance, insurance and repairs?
  3. Are there hours, usage or condition limits with charges at return?
  4. What are the early termination terms?
  5. Is there a purchase option, and at what price?
  6. What happens if the vendor goes out of business or discontinues support?

Wear-and-tear clauses can be costly on equipment used hard. Get the return conditions in writing.

Compare with other financing

Put the lease next to a loan, including USDA options found through farmers.gov, your ag lender's equipment loan and dealer financing. Build a sheet with total cost over the same period, adjusted for what you'd own or owe at the end. Include tax effects using your accountant's numbers.

Use the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker for lease-versus-buy worksheets and farm management guidance. Finally, ask yourself how you will feel in the last year of the lease. If the answer is "stuck," read the contract again.