How do I handle milk price volatility?

Know your class, cover your margin

LANCASTER, Wisconsin — A dairy processor handles milk price volatility by understanding how your milk is priced, building those costs into your own prices, locking in some costs when you can, and keeping enough cash to ride out the swings. Prices for milk and dairy commodities move with supply, demand, trade and feed costs, and no processor controls them. What you control is how much of your margin depends on guessing. Start with how your milk is priced, then work on pricing, contracts and reserves.

You can't predict the milk market, and anyone who says they can is selling something.

Understand how your milk is priced

In much of the country, minimum prices for milk are set under Federal Milk Marketing Orders, which classify milk by use, such as fluid products, soft products, cheese, or butter and powder, and publish class prices. Which class your product falls in affects your cost. Prices are announced by USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service, and market reports are at AMS Market News. Some states regulate prices on their own, and some areas fall outside the orders. Ask your state department of agriculture and your milk supplier how your price is calculated, whether there are premiums, and when prices are announced. Dairy Markets and farmdoc daily track market movement.

Pass costs through pricing

Build pricing that reflects milk cost. Many processors adjust wholesale prices on a schedule tied to a published milk price, with a clear notice period to customers. Others use price lists revised quarterly. Discuss with buyers early: a customer who understands why prices moved is less likely to leave. Know your break-even milk price, the level at which a product's margin goes to zero, and watch it against current prices. Avoid long fixed-price sales agreements unless your milk cost is also fixed.

Use contracts and tools carefully

Options include fixed-price or formula contracts with milk suppliers, forward contracts, and futures or options for hedging. Hedging is complicated and can lose money; if you consider it, learn it with an advisor or broker and start small. Written contracts with your suppliers can set formulas, premiums and limits. Check AgMRC for market information and talk to your lender and accountant. Don't commit to anything you can't explain in a sentence.

Diversify your product mix

Products priced differently can offset each other. Some items, like premium aged cheese or specialty products, may be less sensitive to a commodity price swing than a bulk product. A mix of fluid, cultured and aged products spreads risk, though it adds complexity. Review margins by product, and move capacity to what pays in current conditions.

Build a cushion

Keep a cash reserve and a line of credit for tight months. Run your forecast at low and high milk prices to see what breaks. Keep debt payments manageable. Tell your lender early if conditions change; lenders prefer a phone call to a surprise. Keep an eye on your farm suppliers too. If they're losing money, your supply is at risk. The USDA Farm Service Agency programs for producers may affect your suppliers' decisions, so know what's available to them.

Review the numbers monthly, and write down your decisions so you learn from each cycle.