How are milk prices set?

From the cheese vat to your check

MADISON, Wisconsin — Milk prices are set by a mix of federal formulas, market prices for dairy products, the way your milk is used, and the contract you have with your buyer. Most farmers in the United States get a monthly check built from a minimum price calculated under a federal order, adjusted by what the cooperative or processor adds or subtracts. No one person sets the price, which is cold comfort when the check is small, but it does mean you can learn to read it.

This article lays out the parts of the system and where to find each current number.

The base: product prices drive milk prices

Milk gets priced backward from what it can be made into. Cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and dry whey are traded and reported weekly. The federal system takes those wholesale prices, subtracts a standard allowance for the cost of making each product, and converts what's left into prices for butterfat, protein and other solids. That's why a drop in the cheese market eventually shows up in your milk check, even though you never touched a block of cheddar.

The National Agricultural Statistics Service collects the product price survey that feeds the formulas, and the Agricultural Marketing Service announces the resulting minimum prices.

Classes of milk

Milk is priced by how it is used. Class I is fluid drinking milk. Class II is soft products like ice cream and yogurt. Class III is cheese and whey, and Class IV is butter and dry milk. Each class has its own minimum price calculated from product prices, and each month a pool of money is created from the value of all milk used. Farmers in a federal order are paid a blended price reflecting the mix of uses in their order.

The differences between classes explain why neighbors in different regions can see different blended prices even when the same markets move. More fluid milk use in an order generally lifts the blend, because Class I carries extra location-based adders.

Federal milk marketing orders

Federal milk marketing orders are regional rules run by USDA that set minimum prices that regulated processors must pay, and they pool proceeds so producers share in the value of all uses. Not all milk is under a federal order, and a few states run their own pricing programs. Whether you're in an order depends on where your milk is delivered, not necessarily where the cows live.

You can read order information and the announced prices on the AMS dairy pages. Your milk handler's statement should show which order the milk falls in and how the blend price was calculated.

Premiums, deductions and your contract

The federal minimum is a floor, not the check. Cooperatives and processors add premiums for quality, components, volume or hauling, and take out charges for hauling, marketing, capital retains, advertising programs and sometimes balancing costs. Quality payments often rely on somatic cell counts and bacteria counts. Two farms in the same order may take home different amounts because of components, quality and contract terms.

Ask your milk buyer for a plain written explanation of every line on your statement. If they use a base-excess plan, ask how the base is set. If you can sell to more than one handler, ask each for a sample check using last month's milk.

Where to see the current numbers

Current announced prices are on the AMS dairy market news pages and in your order's monthly announcements. For analysis, university sites like farmdoc daily discuss dairy margins and price patterns, and Dairy Markets tracks price information for producers. The Economic Research Service publishes background on how dairy pricing works.

Remember that announced minimums change monthly, and I'm not quoting any here. Pull the latest from the source.

Steps to take

  1. Get your last three milk statements and mark each line.
  2. Find the order that covers your milk and read its price announcements.
  3. Track the product prices that feed the formula.
  4. Compare your pay price to the announced minimum to see your premiums and deductions.
  5. Consider risk tools, such as the margin protection programs and futures, that your lender or advisor can explain.

Prices are set through a formula you can learn. Once you do, a check that looked like a mystery turns into arithmetic, and arithmetic can be argued with.