How do co-ops set milk prices?

What goes into the milk check

DECORAH, Iowa — Co-ops don't invent milk prices from scratch. They start with the minimum prices set by the Federal Milk Marketing Order or state system, add or subtract premiums and costs, factor in what their plants earn selling products and then announce a pay price to members, typically monthly. Two co-ops in the same region can announce different pay prices for the same month because of different products, plants, costs and policies. Understanding the pieces helps you read your statement.

The starting point: the regulated minimum

For milk priced under a federal order, USDA announces class prices derived from wholesale prices of cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and whey, as reported through AMS Market News. The order pools the value of all classes and distributes it to producers as a blended price, adjusted for location and for components such as butterfat and protein. A co-op that sells most of its milk into cheese will see its returns follow the cheese-related class price closely.

The regulated minimum is what handlers owe. Co-ops, as handlers, often pay members based on that blend and then add or subtract their own adjustments.

Premiums and market adjustments

Many buyers pay premiums above the minimum for things like location, quality, volume or special programs. The co-op negotiates these and passes them to members according to its rules. Over-order premiums, as they are often called, are one of the most variable parts of a milk check and the one where negotiation has the most effect.

Costs that come off the top

Co-ops subtract costs to run the business. Typical deductions include hauling, marketing or membership fees, the national checkoff assessment, any retained equity and charges for balancing or services. The US Dairy site explains the checkoff. Deductions differ by co-op, so two members with the same gross price may see different net checks.

Plant-owning co-ops

If the co-op manufactures products, its board decides how much of the plant's earnings go to members as price versus retained for investments. A co-op building a new cheese plant may pay members less in the short run. A co-op with an older plant and strong sales may pay more. Neither is automatically better. Look at the co-op's annual report and ask about capital plans.

Pay price announcements and what to read

Co-ops usually publish a monthly pay price or memo to members. Read it for:

Compare those numbers to the published order prices from AMS and analysis from farmdoc daily or Dairy Markets. If the gap between your pay price and the published price changes without explanation, ask why.

Who makes the decisions

The board of directors sets pay policy and approves major business decisions, guided by management. Members vote for directors, so you have a say. Annual meetings, member newsletters and district meetings are where those decisions get explained.

Questions to ask

  1. What percent of our milk goes into each product class?
  2. What premiums did we receive, and how are they distributed?
  3. What changed in deductions compared with last year?
  4. What are the plans for equity retirement?

You don't need to be an economist to read a milk check. You need a highlighter, the published prices and the patience to ask the field rep the same question twice if the first answer was fuzzy.