How do federal milk marketing orders work?

Regional rules, pooled pay

SPRINGFIELD, Missouri — Federal milk marketing orders are regional regulations that set minimum prices processors must pay for milk based on how it is used, then pool the proceeds so all farmers in that order share in the total value. They exist because milk is perishable, farmers are numerous and handlers are few, so left alone the market gave farmers a weak bargaining hand. The orders try to even that out and make pricing more orderly.

The sections below cover how an order is built, who is regulated, how the pool works and where you can read the details.

What an order is

An order is a set of rules for a geographic area, adopted by USDA after a hearing and a vote by the farmers involved. It sets minimum prices by class, defines which plants are covered, and describes how payments are made. USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service administers the orders, and each one has a market administrator's office that audits handlers and calculates the pool.

Orders don't set the price a cooperative or processor must offer, only the minimum a regulated handler must pay. Many buyers pay over the minimum through premiums. The list of orders and their maps are on the AMS website.

Who is regulated

Orders regulate handlers, which are the plants and distributors that buy milk, not the farms. A handler is covered by an order based on where it distributes its products. A farm is in an order depending on where its milk is delivered. A few states have their own price regulation, and some milk is not under any order, which is why it pays to ask your buyer which system applies to you.

Small processors can be partially regulated or exempt depending on volume, so if you bottle on the farm, ask the market administrator or your state dairy office how an order affects you.

How classes and pooling work

Handlers report to the market administrator how much milk they received and what they made from it. Each pound is assigned to a class, and the handler owes the pool the difference between the value of its milk at class prices and the average. Money is paid out of the pool to handlers whose milk was used in lower-value classes, so every producer in the order gets paid a blend of all uses. That blend price is what the order announces for farmers.

This is why a farm shipping to a cheese plant and a farm shipping to a bottling plant in the same order can receive the same blend before premiums. The pool is also why Class I location adjustments, called differentials, matter for regions that rely on fluid sales.

Component pricing and payments to farmers

Most orders now pay on components, meaning butterfat, protein and other solids, with adjustments for somatic cell counts in many cases. Your statement should show hundredweight shipped, test results, and a price for each part. Payment deadlines are set by the order, and handlers must pay by certain dates, which helps if you are chasing an overdue check.

Some orders include deductions for hauling or a producer-settlement fund, and many cooperatives add their own charges. Read the whole statement. If you cannot match the numbers, ask for a written reconciliation.

How orders change

Orders can be amended through a hearing process that lets farmers, co-ops and processors present testimony. Proposals and decisions are published in the Federal Register, and public comments can be filed at Regulations.gov. If a change affects your farm, you can submit comments or vote through your cooperative. The Congressional Research Service has published neutral background reports on dairy policy.

I'm not describing any specific current amendments, since they change, so check the dockets.

Questions to ask

  1. Which order covers my milk, and where is my handler's plant?
  2. How is my blend price calculated and what are my premiums and deductions?
  3. Is my buyer fully regulated, partially regulated or exempt?
  4. How does my co-op use its authority to make deductions?
  5. How do I participate in hearings or votes?

Learn your order's name and get on its email list. The market administrator publishes monthly statistics that can answer most of your questions, and the staff are used to farmers calling.