How do I balance forage and grain for dairy goats?

Feed the rumen first, the bucket second

NASHVILLE, Tennessee — You balance forage and grain for dairy goats by feeding as much good forage as the doe will eat, then using grain only to fill the energy and protein gap her milk production creates. The goal is a rumen that stays healthy and milk fat that holds up, without a doe losing too much weight. Too much grain causes acidosis and wastes money. Too little leaves production on the table. Here's a practical method for finding the middle.

Know what forage can do

A doe on high-quality forage can meet a good part of her needs, particularly in mid and late lactation. Leafy alfalfa or clover-grass hay, or fresh pasture and browse in the growing season, supply protein and energy along with fiber. Forage quality decides how much grain you'll need.

Test your hay. Send a sample to a lab for protein, fiber and energy values. Compare lots, because one cutting can be very different from another. Extension sources such as Kansas State's Research and Extension and Noble Research Institute offer forage information that applies to many regions. When you know the numbers, you can estimate how much of the doe's need the forage covers.

Estimate the gap

The doe's needs depend on her body weight, milk yield, milk fat and stage of lactation. A high producer in early lactation has a big gap between what she needs and what forage can supply, and goats usually can't eat enough to close it. Mid-lactation does with moderate output need less. Dry does need maintenance and, late in gestation, a bit more.

Work with a nutritionist or extension specialist, or use a published requirement table or software, to calculate the gap. A simple rule used in many dairies is to feed grain in proportion to milk produced, so higher producers get more. That requires milk weights, which is another reason to keep records.

Feed grain in a way that protects the rumen

How you feed grain matters as much as how much. Introduce changes gradually over a week or more. Split the daily amount into at least two feedings rather than one big meal, and feed some forage before or with the grain. Buffering and keeping fiber levels adequate help prevent acidosis.

Watch for warning signs: does going off feed, loose or foamy manure, bloat, and a drop in milk fat. If you see them, reduce grain, increase forage and call your veterinarian. Some does are more sensitive than others, and a bold doe can crowd out a shy one at a feeder, so give enough bunk space.

Group and adjust

If you can, group does by production or stage. High producers get a richer ration, and low producers and dry does get less. That saves feed and avoids fat does. Without grouping, use individual feeding in the parlor for the grain portion, so you can scale it by doe.

Adjust as lactation advances. Grain amounts should fall as milk declines, with forage making up more of the diet. Revisit the ration when forage changes, when you move from pasture to hay, or when weather shifts. Body condition scoring every month or so, by feel, tells you if you're on target.

Watch the economics

Grain costs money, and forage often costs less per unit of nutrient, especially if you grow it. Compare your feed cost per unit of milk. Sometimes one more pound of grain gives enough additional milk to pay. Sometimes it doesn't. Keep milk weights and feed records to find out. Your price for milk or cheese matters, and so does the response of your does. The Agricultural Marketing Resource Center and Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker offer budgeting information that can help.

Improving forage quality is usually the best return. Earlier cutting, better storage, better pasture management and rotation can reduce grain needs. ATTRA has resources on pasture-based goat systems.

A simple routine

Test forage, estimate the need, feed grain in the parlor by production, keep minerals and water available, and score body condition regularly. Write down what you feed and what comes back in the tank. Every few weeks, look at the numbers and adjust one thing at a time. A ration that supports steady milk, good body condition and healthy manure is balanced, even if it doesn't match the textbook. And if a doe looks at the grain bucket like she's never been fed, keep in mind that she acts that way every day.