How do I benchmark reproductive performance?

Pick a few numbers, compare them fairly

SHEBOYGAN, Wisconsin — Benchmarking reproduction means measuring your herd's key numbers and comparing them with a fair standard, either your own past results or those of similar herds. The point isn't to feel good or bad. It's to find which part of the breeding program is costing you the most and work on that.

A short list of well-defined numbers beats a long list nobody trusts. Here's how to set it up.

Choose a few core measures

Common reproductive measures include pregnancy rate, conception rate, heat detection rate, days open, services per conception, calving interval and the share of cows pregnant by a target day in milk. Many herd software programs and DHI reports calculate them. Pregnancy rate is popular because it combines heat detection and conception. Read how your software defines each measure, because definitions vary.

Be sure the data is clean

Benchmarks are only as good as records. Check for missing breedings, unrecorded pregnancy checks and wrong dates. A herd that doesn't record all breedings will look better or worse than it is. Fix record-keeping first; see the article on recording reproduction data on this site.

Pick a fair comparison

Compare yourself against:

Be careful when comparing with very different herds. A pasture-based seasonal herd and a year-round confinement herd run different timelines. Ask what the other herd's definitions are.

Split the numbers

Break results out by parity, season, breeding method, technician, sire and cow group. A good overall number can hide a bad group, such as first-calf heifers, summer breedings or cows bred on a timed program. Splitting shows where to act.

Link to dollars

Estimate what a day open costs your herd, using your milk price and feed costs, and convert gaps in performance into money. That helps you decide where to spend time and funds. Ask your accountant, vet or an Extension farm management specialist to help. Wisconsin's farm management resources provide tools.

Review on a schedule

Look at the numbers monthly and do a deeper review a few times a year with your vet and nutritionist. Chart trends. One bad week isn't a trend; three bad months is.

Set goals and follow through

Set a goal for one or two measures, name who is responsible and set a date to review. Repeat. For example, pick heat detection first, then conception, then transition health.

Know where the benchmarks come from

Check the sources for current targets, since recommended goals change with technology and genetics. The American Association of Bovine Practitioners and Extension programs can point you to current targets. Avoid relying on a number you heard at a meeting years ago.

Benchmarking works when it changes what you do on Monday morning. If the report doesn't change a task, the report isn't doing its job.