How do I calculate DMC payments?

The margin math, step by step

CORTLAND, New York — A Dairy Margin Coverage payment is the gap between your chosen coverage level and the national margin for the month, multiplied by the amount of production you've covered. If the margin is at or above your level, the payment is zero. The math is simple enough to do on the back of a feed tag. The harder part is getting the right inputs, and those come from USDA, not from your own books.

The formula details, such as how the feed cost is built and how production is divided into months, are set in program rules and can change, so confirm the specifics with the Farm Service Agency.

The basic formula

For a given month, FSA announces the national margin. Compare it with your chosen coverage level. If the margin is lower, subtract the margin from your level to get the payment rate per hundredweight. Then multiply that rate by the production you've covered for that month. Covered production comes from your enrolled production history and the portion you elected, divided to a monthly amount. So the calculation looks like this: payment rate times covered monthly hundredweights equals the payment. Premiums and any fees are separate, and FSA may handle them when it pays. The program page at the Farm Service Agency lays out the method and has the current rules.

Where the margin number comes from

The margin is the national average all-milk price minus the national feed cost formula. The milk price and feed ingredient prices come from USDA price reports, in particular reports from the National Agricultural Statistics Service. The feed formula blends national prices of feed ingredients using fixed proportions set in the rules. FSA calculates and posts the result, so you don't have to build it yourself, but doing it yourself is a good way to understand why the margin moved. A mismatch between your estimate and FSA's number usually means a different data source or a timing difference.

A worked example in words

Say your chosen level is one number and the national margin for a month comes out a bit lower. Subtract and you get a rate per hundredweight. Now say your covered production for that month is a certain number of hundredweights. Multiply the rate by that number. That's the pre-adjustment payment. Notice the structure: the payment depends only on the gap, not on whether your farm made or lost money that month. A farm with strong components and cheap home-raised feed might collect while earning a decent profit. Another might lose money and collect nothing. This isn't a bug, just a feature of a national formula.

Check your covered production

Many mistakes come from misunderstanding what's covered. Ask FSA to show you on paper:

Your payment depends on those figures, so confirm them when you sign up and again if you see an unexpected payment amount. Also ask when payments are issued after a month is calculated, and how they're delivered.

How to double-check a payment

  1. Look up the posted national margin for the month.
  2. Compare it with your coverage level.
  3. Calculate the rate per hundredweight.
  4. Multiply by your covered monthly production.
  5. Compare with the payment notice, accounting for fees, premium handling and any adjustments.
  6. If it doesn't match, call your county office and ask them to walk through the calculation.

Keep your enrollment paperwork, since it's the best evidence if you need to dispute anything. Another useful source for working through examples is farmdoc daily, which has published explanations of the math. FSA staff handle these questions all the time, so don't feel bad asking.