How do I calibrate a cheese thermometer?
Ice water and boiling water
LOGAN, Utah — Calibrating a cheese thermometer takes about five minutes and two cups of water. Cheese recipes depend on narrow temperature windows, and a thermometer that's off by a few degrees can change curd set, acid development and cooking time. The two standard checks are ice water, which should read 32 degrees F, and boiling water, which reads about 212 degrees F at sea level and lower at altitude. Here's how to test, adjust and know when a thermometer needs replacing, so you stop blaming the cow for what the probe did.
The ice water test
Fill a glass with crushed ice, then add cold water until the glass is full but the ice still floats. Stir for about a minute. Put the probe in the middle of the glass, away from the sides and bottom, and wait for the reading to settle. Crushed ice works better than cubes because it packs around the probe.
It should read 32 degrees F or 0 degrees C. If it reads 34, your thermometer runs two degrees high. Write that down and tape the note to the thermometer case. Don't let the probe touch the glass, which can sit a degree or two off the water temperature.
The boiling water test
Bring a pot of clean water to a full rolling boil. Insert the probe in the middle, not touching the bottom, and wait for a steady reading. Use the same depth each time so results are comparable.
Water boils at 212 degrees F at sea level, but the boiling point drops by roughly one degree F for every 500 feet of elevation. If you farm in the high plains or mountains, look up your local boiling point or check it against a trusted source such as your local weather service or Extension office. Weather also shifts it slightly from day to day, so treat the boiling test as a check, not a precise standard.
Adjust the thermometer
Many dial thermometers have a nut under the head. Hold the probe in ice water and turn the nut until the needle reads 32. Digital thermometers may have a calibration button or setting, so check the manual for the steps. Some inexpensive models can't be adjusted at all.
If yours can't adjust, record the error and add or subtract it when reading. If a thermometer is off by different amounts at the two test points, it's worn out, and the correction won't hold across the range. Replace it. A reliable probe thermometer costs less than a single ruined vat.
Check before big batches
Calibrate whenever you buy a new thermometer, drop one or notice odd results. A quick ice-water test before each make takes a minute. Keep one reference thermometer that you only use for checking others, and never use it in a pot of milk.
Use thermometers rated for the range you need. Cheese work covers roughly the range from refrigerator temperature up to near boiling for stretching and cooking. Waterproof digital probes are easy to clean and sanitize, and a long cord or probe lets you read the temperature without lifting the lid.
Clean it and learn the readings
Wash and sanitize the probe between uses, and don't store it in a wet drawer. Look for cracked glass in glass thermometers, and replace any that show a separated column of liquid. Don't use mercury thermometers around food.
Digital thermometers can drift as batteries weaken, so swap the battery before a big make day. For more help, see eXtension, Penn State Extension, USDA FSIS food-safety thermometer guidance and the National Agricultural Library.
Don't forget the other side of the range either. For cheeses that rely on cold steps, like brining or holding milk before culturing, a thermometer that reads right near 40 degrees F matters too. A quick check in an ice bath covers the low end, and a comparison with a second thermometer in the refrigerator tells you whether the fridge is holding the temperature you think it is.
Some makers calibrate twice, once at the start of the season and once on a make day, and keep a small log. Over a year you can see whether a probe is drifting. A thermometer that has been dropped, left in a hot oven or soaked in a sanitizer bath for hours deserves an extra check before it goes back into a vat of good milk.
Four degrees of error won't stop a milkshake. It will ruin a cheddar.