How do I choose a DMC coverage level?

A step-by-step method

ELLENSBURG, Washington — Choosing a Dairy Margin Coverage level comes down to three questions: how much margin do you need to stay solvent, how much does each level cost, and how much of that cost can you afford to pay against the chance you'll never collect? Answer those with your own records and the published premium table, and the choice gets a lot less mysterious. It won't be perfect, because nobody knows future prices, but it'll be reasoned.

Here's a method you can run at the kitchen table in an evening.

Step one: find your break-even

Pull together a year of costs and milk sales. Figure your cost per hundredweight, including purchased feed, home-raised feed at a fair value, labor, vet and breeding, utilities, repairs, interest, depreciation and family living. Divide by hundredweights sold. Then add what you need for principal payments. That total, in per-hundredweight terms, is the margin you need over feed to keep going. Records from your milk checks and bookkeeping software work fine. The Center for Farm Financial Management offers financial analysis resources, and the Iowa State agricultural decision maker site publishes cost-of-production worksheets.

Step two: get the actual numbers from FSA

Ask your county Farm Service Agency office for the current coverage options, premium rates, administrative fee and rules on how much of your production history you can cover. Don't work from memory or from what someone said at a meeting, because these figures can change. Also ask whether multi-year options exist and how they work. Write the numbers down. If you can't find the table on the FSA site, ask staff to email it to you.

Step three: test the levels against history

Take each coverage level and ask how much it would have paid in past years, using the historical national margin data that FSA and university sites publish. Compare that to the premium you'd have paid. Past results don't predict future ones, but they show you how often margins have dipped into each range. Several university tools let you plug in numbers and see the result. farmdoc daily has published analysis on this kind of testing, and extension dairy specialists often run workshops on it. Look at the pattern, not just the average, since the program is designed for the occasional bad stretch.

Step four: fit it to your risk

Match the level to your financial position. A farm with high debt and thin reserves may value a higher floor. A farm with low debt and strong cash may take more risk. Consider your lender's view, since many will want to know your risk plan. Also consider your other tools. If you already carry price protection through your buyer or a revenue insurance policy bought through an agent via RMA, you might choose a lower DMC level, or you might use DMC to cover the margin side that insurance doesn't.

Step five: decide and write it down

  1. Note your break-even margin.
  2. Note the premium for each level you're considering.
  3. Note what each would have paid in past years.
  4. Choose, and record your reasoning in a paragraph.
  5. Next year, reread the paragraph and see how you did.

A few cautions

Don't pick the highest level just because it feels safe, since you pay for that comfort. Don't pick the lowest just because you've had a good run. Don't ignore the production share you're covering, since it affects both premium and payment. Don't wait until the final day to ask questions. And keep in mind the national margin isn't your margin, so a payment may not match your actual losses. If you've got an old milk-truck driver who's seen a few cycles, that conversation's worth fifteen minutes too.