How do I comment on milk pricing rules?
Public comment, step by step
WAUSAU, Wisconsin — You comment on milk pricing rules by finding the proposal in the Federal Register or on regulations.gov, reading the notice, submitting a written comment before the posted closing time and, for formal hearings, signing up to testify. The process is open to anyone, farmers included. Agencies are required to consider substantive comments, and a comment from a farmer describing real milk checks can carry more weight than a form letter signed by thousands. Here is how to do it well.
Find the proposal
Milk pricing changes come through several channels. Federal Milk Marketing Order amendments are noticed in the Federal Register, where you can search for "milk" or "marketing order" and sign up for email alerts. Comment dockets live at regulations.gov, which lets you read other people's comments and submit your own. The USDA Agricultural Marketing Service posts hearing notices and decisions on its dairy pages.
State milk pricing rules go through your state's own process, usually through the department of agriculture or a milk board. Look for a rulemaking page and a public notice list.
Understand the notice before you write
Every notice states what's proposed, the legal basis, how to submit comments and the deadline. Do not guess about the deadline; read it, write it on the calendar and plan to file early. Systems clog near closing time.
Then read the proposal itself, not only a summary. Ask: what changes in the formula or rule? Who gains or loses? What does the agency say it is trying to fix? Many notices include a section on economic effects that explains the agency's reasoning.
Write a comment that gets read
Short, specific and personal beats long and generic. A good comment typically:
- Says who you are (dairy farmer, location, herd size, co-op or handler)
- States clearly whether you support or oppose the proposal, or parts of it
- Gives reasons, with examples from your own milk checks or costs
- Suggests an alternative if you oppose something
- References the specific section or docket number
Stay civil. Skip the insults; they make a comment easier to dismiss. Avoid claiming facts you cannot support. If you cite a number, say where it came from.
Formal hearings and testimony
For some order changes, USDA holds a public hearing with witnesses, exhibits and cross-examination. Farmers can testify, but it is a formal setting and preparation helps. Cooperatives and farm groups often coordinate witnesses, so your co-op may be a good way to participate. Ask your board or field rep whether they plan to testify and whether a producer voice is needed. Written statements may also be accepted, depending on the notice.
Use your organizations wisely
Groups like the Farm Bureau, National Farmers Union and your cooperative will often file comments on your behalf. That's helpful, but their positions may not match yours. Ask to see what they filed. If you disagree, file your own comment as well.
What happens after you submit
The agency reviews comments, may respond in its decision or final rule and sometimes changes the proposal. Don't expect a personal reply. Do check later documents for how your point was treated. If a vote or referendum follows, as with some order amendments, that is your chance to vote on the outcome directly, so watch for ballots from the market administrator.
Keep a copy of what you submitted and the confirmation number. If your local paper never covers this stuff, don't take it personally; your comment still counts, and it is probably more read than the sports page in the dairy offices anyway.