How do I compare co-op pay prices?

Compare checks on equal footing

FOND DU LAC, Wisconsin — To compare co-op pay prices fairly, you have to compare net returns on the same milk, with the same components, hauling and deductions, over several months, not one headline price. A co-op advertising a high base price can come out behind one with a lower base but smaller deductions and better premiums. The work is mostly arithmetic, plus a few awkward questions. Here is a method that keeps you from comparing apples to a different, slightly sneakier apple.

Start with your own milk

Pull your last several milk statements. Note your pounds, butterfat, protein, other solids, somatic cell count, bacteria count and any quality or volume premiums. Your milk is not average, so the comparison has to use your numbers. If a competing co-op or handler is willing to quote you, give them your real component and quality data.

Get comparable quotes

Ask each buyer for the same items in writing:

  1. The price formula (base, components, adjustments)
  2. Premiums for quality, volume, location or other programs
  3. Hauling charges and how they are calculated
  4. Other deductions, including membership fees, equity retains and assessments
  5. Payment timing and any holdbacks
  6. Contract length, notice to leave and exit costs

A verbal promise won't help you if the pay price shifts later. Ask for the written terms and keep them.

Work out net, not gross

Build a simple spreadsheet. For one representative month, apply each buyer's formula to your milk, subtract deductions and include premiums. Then run the same calculation across several months to see how it behaves when markets move. A price that looks excellent in a month with strong cheese values may look different when markets turn.

University tools can help. The Center for Farm Financial Management offers farm financial resources, and extension dairy specialists in your state may offer worksheets. See also farmdoc daily for analysis of how milk pricing formulas behave.

Check the benchmark

Compare each pay price against published prices: federal order class prices and announced blend prices on the AMS site and Market News. If a co-op consistently pays below the order's announced blend, ask what costs account for the difference. If another pays above, ask how sustainable that is. Premiums that depend on one big customer or a special program may not last.

Weigh the non-price factors

Price isn't the whole story. Consider:

A buyer that pays a bit less but picks up every day and never misses a check can be worth more than one with a spectacular number and a shaky balance sheet.

Make the switch carefully

Before moving, read your current membership agreement for notice periods and equity terms. Moving milk can trigger deadlines and penalties. Talk to your lender, since a change in payor may affect assignments or loan terms. Ask a neutral third party, such as an extension educator, to look over the numbers.

Finally, compare again every year or two. Markets and deductions shift. Your current co-op may be the best fit, and if so, you'll sleep better knowing why.