How do I compare my milk price to neighbors?

Fair comparisons start with the same basis

MARSHFIELD, Wisconsin — To compare your milk price to a neighbor's fairly, you need to compare the same things: the same pricing basis, the same components, the same deductions and the same time period. Comparing the number at the bottom of two checks tells you very little, because one farm might ship higher components, haul further or belong to a different cooperative. The comparison that matters is net price after adjusting for those differences.

Also, expect neighbors to be a little vague about their numbers. Farmers will describe a good day's weather in detail, but milk checks get described with a shrug.

Compare the same things

Start by choosing a unit, usually net dollars per hundredweight, and a period, such as the last twelve months. Make a list of what's included in your price: base price, component premiums, quality premiums, volume or hauling adjustments, pooling or marketing order adjustments and deductions for hauling, promotion, cooperative fees and capital retains.

Then ask whether your neighbor's numbers include the same items. A neighbor who quotes the headline price without deductions will always look better than a farm that reports the net. If they're willing, swap the full statement lines, not only the summary.

Component levels also matter. Two farms can have the same price schedule and very different checks because of butterfat and protein tests. Compare tests alongside prices.

Use published benchmarks

You don't have to rely on neighbors alone. The National Agricultural Statistics Service and AMS Market News publish regional price information, including the average mailbox price, which is an all-in price received after deductions. Compare your net to the figure for your marketing area and period.

The Economic Research Service also publishes dairy data and outlook material that explains regional differences. Check the agency's site for the current reports and how each is defined. A good benchmark states exactly what it includes, so read the definitions before comparing.

Look at the reasons for the gap

If your price differs from the benchmark or from neighbors, sort the causes:

  1. Components: are your butterfat and protein above or below the regional average?
  2. Quality: are your somatic cell and bacteria counts earning premiums or losing them?
  3. Volume: does your buyer pay for volume or size of load?
  4. Location: how far is your farm from the plant and what is the hauling charge?
  5. Contract terms: are you on a different pricing formula than your neighbors?
  6. Marketing order: are you in the same order and pool?

Each of these has a different fix. Components and quality respond to nutrition and herd management. Hauling and volume depend on your location and buyer. Contract terms can only be changed by negotiation or changing buyers, if that's even an option where you farm.

A worked comparison

Say you and a neighbor both want to compare twelve months of milk. List total payments, total deductions and total hundredweight for each farm. Divide net by hundredweight. If your neighbor's figure is higher, line up the pieces: butterfat and protein tests, quality premiums, hauling charges and cooperative deductions. Often the difference comes from one or two items, like component levels or a premium that you're close to earning. That gives you a target instead of a vague feeling that someone else got a better deal.

Learn from neighbors without handing over your books

Many farmers join discussion groups, benchmarking programs or extension workshops where data is shared anonymously or in aggregate. State extension offices and farm business management associations run such programs. The University of Minnesota Center for Farm Financial Management and your state's extension dairy program are good starting points.

If you want to share numbers with a neighbor, do it on paper with specific lines, and agree on what stays between you. Keep it friendly. Nobody enjoys finding out they're paid less, and nobody enjoys being the person who is paid more.

Decide what to do with the answer

If your net price is below comparable farms, ask your field representative for an explanation in writing, line by line. Ask whether premiums are available that you aren't earning. If you have options among buyers, compare their price schedules, not just the headline numbers.

If your price is at or above the benchmark, look at your costs instead. A strong price with a high cost of production isn't a win. The goal is margin, so keep comparing price and cost together. Your extension dairy specialist can help interpret your statement in an hour or less, and that hour often pays for itself.