How do I evaluate a co-packer?

Check the plant, not the pitch

LOUISVILLE, Kentucky — Evaluate a co-packer by checking food safety first, capability second, and price last. A low quote from a plant with a weak sanitation record is not a deal. It's a delayed recall. The process is simple but takes discipline: write down what you need, ask for documents, visit in person, run a trial, and compare candidates on the same terms. Treat it like hiring a key employee who will also handle your customers' food.

Start with food safety and regulatory standing

Ask for proof of current license or permits for the products you want made. Ask your state regulator to confirm status and recent inspection history, since many agencies make results available on request or publicly. Ask about third-party audits and what they cover. You aren't looking for a perfect record, because everyone has findings. You're looking for honest handling of them and corrections that stuck.

Request their written food safety plan, recall plan, allergen controls and sanitation schedules. Ask how they handle environmental monitoring and what they do after a positive result. The AMS audit programs show one way audits are organized. For dairy, your state agency and the FDA are the main authorities, so check with them about requirements for your type of product.

Judge capability and fit

A clean plant that can't make your product is still the wrong plant. Check equipment against your recipe: vat size, pasteurizer type, filler, culture handling, aging space, cold chain. Ask about minimum run size, lead time, and capacity in your busy season. Ask what share of their capacity your business would use. If you'd be 50 percent of their work, you have bargaining power and risk. If you'd be 1 percent, you may be the first account dropped in a crunch.

Ask what they currently make and for whom. Look for similar products and experience with your milk type, culture or aging style. Ask about staff turnover and who would actually run your batches. The person selling you the service may not be the person at the vat.

Visit, observe and ask for references

Walk the floor. Look for organized storage, clean drains, no standing water, proper handwashing stations, labeled lots, working thermometers, and records kept at point of use. Notice how workers talk about their jobs. A confident crew that explains why it does things is a good sign.

Ask to see a sample production record, a cleaning record and a corrective action example. Ask for two or three customer references, ideally ones with similar products, and actually call them. Ask each reference what went wrong and how it was handled. Everyone has a good story when things go well. What matters is how the plant behaved when it didn't. If you need guidance on organizing the questions, Extension dairy and food specialists can help, and Cornell's small farm program has material on value-added processing.

Run a trial and check the product

Commission a trial batch under the proposed terms. Taste it, test it, and send samples to a lab if your plan calls for it. Check weights, labeling, seals and shelf life, and check that records match the batch. Run a mock traceback: pick a lot and see how quickly they can show ingredients, dates and operators.

If the trial reveals problems, watch how they respond. Do they own it, fix it and document it? Or do they blame your recipe? That reaction predicts most of the relationship. Keep a score sheet with weighted categories like safety, quality, communication, flexibility and cost, so your feelings after a nice lunch don't skew the decision.

Compare cost and terms honestly

Request written quotes with identical assumptions, including minimums, ingredient handling, packaging, storage, shipping and payment terms. Calculate a true cost per unit delivered. Add what it costs you to travel, inspect, and manage the relationship. Use a budgeting tool such as those from the Iowa State ag decision maker or AgMRC to model best and worst cases.

Finally, check the contract terms against your priorities, and get legal review. Re-evaluate your co-packer yearly, with a standing audit of your own, announced or not. The best partners welcome it. If the best price is also the plant you'd least like to eat from, keep looking.