How do I evaluate a new feed product?
Ask for proof, then test it yourself
ELKHORN, Nebraska — You evaluate a new feed product by asking what it claims to do, what evidence backs that claim, what it costs per cow per day, and whether a fair trial on your farm can confirm it. Many additives and supplements promise gains in milk, health or efficiency. Some deliver, some deliver in certain situations, and some deliver mostly to the seller. A clear process keeps you from paying for hope.
Pin down the claim
Ask the rep for the specific benefit, the cow group it applies to, and the conditions under which it works. A claim like "improves rumen health" is vague. A claim like "increases energy-corrected milk in early lactation cows on high-starch diets" is testable. Ask for the active ingredient and what regulatory category the product falls under, since feed additive rules vary. Ask whether the ingredient is already in your ration through another feed. Your extension office or nutritionist can help interpret.
Look at the evidence
Ask for published, peer-reviewed research, not just company summaries or testimonials. Check whether the studies used cows like yours, whether treatments were randomized and replicated, and who funded and ran them. Be wary of results reported without statistics or from a single herd. See our guide to feed trials for what makes one trustworthy. The Nutrient Management Conference proceedings and university extension sites can help you find independent summaries.
Do the math
Work out cost per cow per day and the milk or other benefit needed to cover it. Include extra handling, storage and labor. A product that costs a few cents a cow per day needs a small response to pay, while an expensive one needs a big, reliable response. Ask for the breakeven in your own units, such as liters or pounds of milk per cow, and decide whether the claim is realistic for your herd. Use your current feed cost as the comparison.
Run a trial on your farm
Ask whether the company will supply product for a trial, and design it before you start. Use matched groups, run it long enough to see the effect, and measure dry matter intake, milk, components and health events. Our article on running an on-farm feed trial covers design. Don't change anything else during the test, and agree up front what result means you'll buy or walk away.
Check safety and fit
Ask for the label, guaranteed analysis and any restrictions, like withdrawal times or limits on certain classes of animals. Check that it doesn't duplicate or conflict with minerals or other additives. Ask your veterinarian about health claims. Request that the supplier put recommendations in writing, so you can refer back to them.
Decision checklist
- What exactly does it claim to do?
- What independent evidence supports it?
- What does it cost per cow per day?
- Can I test it fairly?
- What result would make me stop?
A feed product that can't survive a fair test hasn't earned a spot in your mixer.