How do I evaluate AI companies?

Picking an AI semen supplier

WOOSTER, Ohio — In dairy and beef, AI means artificial insemination, and the companies that sell semen and breeding services differ in more than price. Evaluating them is about the quality of the genetics, the quality of the semen and the quality of the service you get when something goes wrong.

Look at the genetics

Ask for sire summaries and understand what each trait means: fertility, calving ease, health, production, longevity, and, for beef, growth and carcass traits. Check how many daughters or progeny a sire's numbers are based on. Young genomic sires have less proof than older proven sires. A company should be willing to explain how it picks and tests its bulls. Compare similar sires across multiple companies, not just the one calling you.

Match the genetics to your goals. A herd selling beef cross calves needs different sires than a herd building its own replacement line.

Check semen quality and fertility data

Ask about the company's semen quality control, how it tests post-thaw motility and how it tracks field fertility. Some sires are listed with a fertility rating from field data; ask how it's calculated. For sexed semen, ask about the conception rate difference compared with conventional semen and what it recommends for heifers versus cows. Be skeptical of claims that cannot be explained.

Evaluate service and support

The person who shows up matters. Ask about technician training, availability during breeding season, help with synchronization programs and reproductive troubleshooting. Do they help with record analysis and herd health? Is there a program for training your own people to inseminate? What happens if a tank fails or a shipment is late? Ask other producers in your area who they use and why.

Handle tanks and storage

Ask about the semen tank program: who owns it, how often it's refilled, and what the service costs. Poor tank handling kills semen. Whether you rent or own the tank, learn the right handling steps, including thawing and keeping straws below the neck of the tank. Your vet or AI technician can train your staff.

Compare the real cost

Price per straw is only part of it. Add technician fees, tank costs, synchronization products and the cost of repeat breedings. A cheaper straw with poor fertility can cost more per pregnancy than a pricier one. Track cost per pregnancy. For general farm business planning, see farmdocdaily.illinois.edu and your state extension office through extension.org.

Ask these questions

  1. How are your sires selected and proven?
  2. Can I see fertility and calving ease data for the sires you recommend?
  3. What is your sexed semen performance in herds like mine?
  4. What technician and troubleshooting support do you offer?
  5. What are all the costs, including tank service?
  6. Can I talk to a few current customers?

Ask your vet for an independent opinion, and look at information from usdairy.com for general dairy industry background. A company that welcomes tough questions is usually a better partner than one that dodges them.