How do I evaluate forage quality for dairy?

Test it, look at it, smell it

LANCASTER, Pennsylvania — Evaluate dairy forage three ways: a lab analysis, a hands-on inspection, and the cow's own response. The lab gives you protein, fiber, digestibility and fermentation numbers. Your eyes and nose catch mold, heating and weedy or stemmy hay the lab might not name. The cow settles the argument by eating it or not. Skip any one of the three and you're guessing.

Sample so the number means something

A bad sample gives a confident wrong answer. For baled hay, use a probe and pull cores from at least a dozen bales per lot, mixing them in a bucket before filling the bag. For silage, take grab samples across the face, not the loose stuff on top, and combine several. Keep lots separate by field, cutting and maturity. Mailing a mixed sample from three cuttings tells you very little about any of them.

Seal the sample, keep it cool, and send it quickly to a lab that is certified or participates in a recognized forage testing program. Ask your extension office which labs they trust.

Read the report in the right order

Look first at dry matter, since everything else is reported on that basis. Then check:

Relative feed value and relative forage quality are index numbers some markets use for hay. They're handy for comparing, but a ration needs the underlying nutrients.

Judge what the lab can't

Walk the bunker or open a bale and use your senses. Mold, a hot spot, a vinegar punch, a rancid smell or a slimy layer all mean lost feed or a feed that cows will refuse. Check for foreign material, soil, weeds, and anything that could injure a cow. Look at the leaf-to-stem ratio in hay; leafy hay carries more protein and digests better.

Silage kernel processing is easy to check. Rinse a one-liter cup of corn silage in water and look for whole or half kernels. Many extension programs publish a scoring method.

Match the forage to the pen

Your best forage belongs in fresh and high cows, where energy density matters most. Lower-quality, higher-fiber forage can go to dry cows, heifers and late-lactation animals. Without testing you'll tend to feed the good stuff everywhere and wonder why feed cost climbs.

The Iowa State Ag Decision Maker and Penn State Extension both publish forage sampling guides, and Purdue Extension has hay and silage resources. AgMRC is useful if you buy or sell hay and want to understand quality terms.

Keep records by lot

Write the lab results on a whiteboard or in a log tied to the field and cutting. Over a few seasons you'll see which fields, harvest windows and storage methods give you better feed. That's the kind of record that changes next year's cutting schedule. A forage test costs far less than a month of milk lost to the wrong ration, which is the argument worth repeating to anyone who thinks sampling is optional.