How do I evaluate manure management technologies?

Test the pitch against your farm

ITHACA, New York — You evaluate manure management technologies by defining the problem you're trying to solve, asking for independent evidence from operations like yours, working out the full cost and labor, and checking rules and markets before you sign. A technology that works beautifully on another farm can fail on yours if the manure, scale or climate differ.

Salespeople talk about what a system can do. Your job is to find out what it does on a farm like yours, every day, in January.

Name the problem first

Write down what you want: lower hauling cost, less odor, better nutrient use, less storage need, energy production, a product to sell, or compliance with a rule. Then rank those goals. A technology that solves a goal you don't have is just an expensive hobby.

Look at your current system's weak points with numbers: volume, hauling distance, nutrient balance, labor hours and storage days. Your nutrient management plan and records will tell you where the pain is. The Cornell Small Farms Program and your state extension office can help you frame the question.

Ask for evidence from similar farms

Request performance data from independent sources such as university trials, extension publications and agency reports, not only vendor materials. Ask the vendor for references with the same species, herd size, bedding type and climate, and call them. Ask what broke, what maintenance it takes and what they'd do differently.

Questions to put to the vendor:

A claim without measurements is just an opinion with a brochure.

Work out the full cost and the cash flow

Add up purchase, installation, engineering, permits, power, repairs, labor, training and downtime. Then compare against the savings or income you can document, and be skeptical of projected revenue from products with uncertain markets. Run the numbers using conservative assumptions, and test what happens if the product price is lower or if repairs run higher.

The farmdoc daily and Iowa State Ag Decision Maker sites offer budgeting tools, and the SBA business plan guide can help you structure a project plan for a lender.

Check rules, markets and fit with your plan

New technology still has to meet your permit and nutrient plan. Ask your state environmental agency how a system would be regulated, including air, water and any waste product handling. Ask your planner how treated or separated products fit your nutrient management plan.

If the system produces something to sell, such as compost, fiber, bedding or energy, find the actual buyer before buying the machine. Ask for a letter of intent or sample contract. Check with your utility, too, if the technology generates power.

Pilot it, then decide

If possible, visit working installations, rent a unit or run a trial before committing. Set measurable targets for the trial: volume handled, nutrient capture, labor hours, cost per unit. Then compare results with your goals.

Bring in a neutral advisor, such as your extension specialist or engineer, to review the proposal. Keep your records and make the decision on numbers. If it passes, buy it. If not, you've saved yourself a very large paperweight.

A written scorecard keeps the evaluation honest. List your goals down the side and give each option a plain score for how well it meets them, how much labor it needs, how long it takes to pay back and how hard it is to fix when it breaks. Include the do-nothing option and the cheap-fix option, such as better storage timing or a calibrated spreader, so the new technology has to beat something real. Share the scorecard with your lender, planner or extension agent and ask them to poke holes in it. If the vendor won't answer a question in writing, treat that as information. Revisit the scorecard after a trial period and keep the paperwork. Good decisions leave a trail, and so do expensive mistakes, so it's better if yours is the first kind. Keep the vendor's answers, quotes and reference names in one folder. If the decision takes months, you'll want to look back at what was promised, and by whom, when the invoice finally shows up.