How do I know if a small ruminant dairy is profitable?
Measure per animal, per unit, per hour
MANHATTAN, Kansas — A small goat or sheep dairy is profitable if, after paying all costs including a fair wage for your own labor, there is money left. That sounds obvious, but many small dairies can't say, because they track cash in the bank instead of income and costs by enterprise. To know, you need a clean set of records, a few simple measures such as income over feed cost and cost per unit of milk, and a regular look at the numbers by month, not just at tax time.
Separate the dairy from everything else
Keep the dairy's income and expenses apart from other enterprises, household spending and hobby animals. Open a separate bank account and set up categories in your accounting records for milk, cheese, kids and other sales, and for feed, labor, vet, supplies, utilities, interest and depreciation. The IRS Publication 225 explains farm income and expense reporting, and your accountant can help with the details.
Value your own and family labor at a market wage. If the dairy only works when your time is free, it isn't profitable, it's subsidized.
Use a few simple measures
Start with income over feed cost per doe or ewe, which links production to your biggest expense. Add total cost per unit of milk, whether per gallon or per pound, and compare it with your selling price. Look at margin per hour of labor, and at net income per animal.
Track break-even: how much milk or product you need to sell to cover all costs. If you're below that point most months, you know where you stand. The Iowa State Ag Decision Maker and farmdoc daily have budgeting tools and articles that work for livestock enterprises.
Include the costs people forget
Depreciation of the parlor, tanks, and vehicles is a real cost even if you don't write a check this year. So are interest, insurance, licensing, testing, replacement animals and your own health insurance. Death losses and culls reduce income, and unsold product is a loss. Be honest about those, because a farm that ignores them looks better than it is.
Facilities debt matters too. A profitable dairy that can't cover loan payments is still in trouble, so compare cash flow with debt service each month.
Check by channel and product
Break results out by product and market. Fluid milk, cheese and kid sales have different margins. Find out which pays best per hour of work, not just per dollar. Farmers market sales may bring higher prices but take more time than wholesale. Use the numbers to decide what to drop. AgMRC and Cornell Small Farms offer enterprise budget examples to compare against.
Compare, then decide
Compare your numbers with last year, with your budget and with peers through extension programs, Minnesota's Center for Farm Financial Management and producer groups. Look for the gaps: high feed cost, low yield, high loss rate, heavy labor. Fix the largest one first.
If the dairy loses money, consider the options: raise yield, cut waste, raise prices, change product mix, reduce herd to the profitable core or add a more profitable market. Sometimes the answer is to stop, and a clear number makes that decision less painful.
Review the numbers every month, and sit down with an advisor once a year. A dairy you can measure is a dairy you can improve, which beats guessing, even if guessing is more fun.
A quick monthly worksheet keeps this manageable. List milk and product sold, other income, then feed, labor, vet, supplies, utilities and loan payments. Divide the profit or loss by the number of milking does, and by hours worked. Compare it with the same month last year and with your budget. Mark any month where you would have been better off working elsewhere for wages, and ask what made the difference. Seasonal swings are normal, so look at trailing twelve-month totals before making big decisions. If you have a lender, share the worksheet with them, since a borrower who knows the numbers tends to get a better hearing.