How do I know when a dairy processor is profitable?

Past the bank balance

BRATTLEBORO, Vermont — A dairy processor is profitable when revenue from products covers all the costs of making and selling them, including milk, labor, packaging, utilities, delivery, loan interest, depreciation and a fair wage for the owner, with something left over. A healthy bank balance doesn't prove it. Cash can look fine because you delayed paying a supplier, skipped equipment replacement, or paid yourself nothing. To know, you need clean books, a break-even calculation and a look at profit by product and by customer.

Plenty of plants are busy and broke at the same time. Busy is not a financial statement.

Read the income statement honestly

Your income statement shows sales minus costs for a period. Look at gross profit, sales minus direct costs like milk, packaging and production labor, and net profit, what remains after overhead, interest and depreciation. Make sure the books assign your own labor a fair wage, even if you pay yourself differently. Use accrual-based accounting if you can, which matches costs to the period when they occur. Ask your accountant to set up accounts that separate milk, packaging, labor, utilities, delivery and overhead. For farm tax background, see IRS Publication 225.

Calculate break-even

Break-even volume equals fixed costs divided by contribution margin per unit, where contribution margin is price minus variable cost. Fixed costs include rent or mortgage, insurance, salaried staff, loan payments and equipment depreciation. Variable costs include milk, packaging and hourly labor tied to volume. If your break-even is higher than what you can sell or make, you're not profitable no matter how busy you are. Update it when milk prices, wages or loan terms change. Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker offers cost and budget tools that can be adapted.

Check profit by product and customer

Total profit can hide losers. Allocate milk, labor, packaging and delivery to each product and calculate margin per unit and per hour of plant time. A product with a high selling price but heavy labor may earn less than a plain one. Do the same by customer: a distant account with small orders may cost more than it brings. Drop, reprice or restructure what loses money.

Separate profit from cash

Profit and cash differ. Growing sales can drain cash because you buy milk before customers pay. Loan principal payments and equipment purchases use cash but don't show as expenses. Track both an income statement and a cash flow forecast. Watch days of receivables and inventory. A plant can be profitable on paper and fail for lack of cash, or have cash and be losing money.

Compare and watch the trend

Compare your results to your own history and plan, month over month and year over year. Look at gross margin, labor percent of sales, waste and yield. Reports from farmdoc daily and AgMRC discuss financial analysis and value-added economics. An agricultural accountant or lender can offer benchmarks for similar plants, though your own trend matters more.

The practical test

Ask: after paying every bill, loan payment and a fair wage to everyone including me, is there money left to replace equipment and handle a bad month? If yes over several consecutive quarters, you're profitable. If not, find the leak.