How do I know when a dairy ration needs changing?

Watch the cows, the feed, and the books

BAKERSFIELD, California — A dairy ration needs changing when the cows, the feed or the economics no longer match what it was built for. The signals include a drop in intake or milk, shifts in components, manure or rumination changes, new forage with different analysis, a change in the group's stage of lactation, or a price shift that makes another formulation cheaper. Don't wait for a crisis; set a regular review and check each of these signals.

Cow signals

Falling dry matter intake, milk yield or components are the first warnings. Loose manure, undigested grain or fiber in manure, drops in rumination, cows sorting through the bunk and weight loss in early lactation point to ration or feeding problems. Rising ketosis, displaced abomasums or lameness can also point to nutrition, though other causes exist. Talk with your veterinarian and nutritionist before changing the ration based on one signal. Penn State Extension has guides on reading cow signals.

Feed signals

A new forage analysis that differs from the last one is a strong reason to revisit the ration. So are changes in dry matter, a switch to a new bunker face, a new hay lot, changes in commodity quality, or spoiled feed. Test forages on a schedule and whenever the source changes. Don't keep feeding the same recipe if the ingredients changed.

Group and herd changes

Cows change stage, groups fill and empty, and herd average production shifts. A ration formulated for a group of high-producing fresh cows doesn't suit a pen that has drifted to late lactation. Review group composition and days in milk regularly. Seasonal calving, new heifers entering and cull decisions can all change the needs of the pen.

Economic signals

Feed prices move. A change in the price of an ingredient may let your nutritionist substitute at lower cost without hurting performance, or may make an expensive ingredient not worth its place. Review income over feed cost, and check current milk prices through USDA AMS Market News. Ask for a cost comparison before big changes.

Weather and management changes

Heat, cold and wet weather change intake and feed quality. New mixing equipment, new staff or changes to feeding times can alter what cows actually eat. If the ration is right on paper but cows are off, check what is delivered.

Set a review schedule

Agree with your nutritionist on a regular review, with extra visits after major changes. Bring forage tests, milk records, mixer logs and manure observations. Make one change at a time where possible and give it enough time to show an effect before changing again.

Quick decision guide

  1. Check feed delivered against the recipe.
  2. Look at intake, milk and manure trends.
  3. Compare the latest forage tests with those used in the ration.
  4. Review group composition and costs.
  5. Make one change, then watch.

A ration is a plan, and plans need updating when the facts change. Check often and the cows will tell you what they need.