How do I make cheese curds for poutine?

Fresh cheddar curds that squeak

STEVENS POINT, Wisconsin — You make poutine curds by making a cheddar curd, milling it into bite-size pieces, salting it, and stopping before the pressing stage, so you end up with small, springy, fresh pieces that squeak against your teeth. Poutine curds are a fresh product, not an aged cheese. The whole point is that they're made the day you plan to use them, or close to it. Old curds lose their squeak and go rubbery. Good ones hold their shape under hot gravy without melting into goo, which is why cheddar curd, rather than mozzarella or shredded cheese, is traditional.

Start with a cheddar-style process

Warm whole milk, add mesophilic starter, let it ripen, then add rennet. When the curd sets, cut it into small cubes, around the size of a pea to a small bean. Cook it gently while stirring, bringing it up slowly so the curd shrinks and firms. Drain the whey when the curd reaches the firmness your recipe calls for.

Use a tested cheddar recipe from a trusted source and follow its temperatures and times. Small changes in cooking and acidity change the final texture a lot.

Cheddaring and milling

The next steps are what separate cheddar curd from other fresh curd. After draining, the curd is pressed together into a mat, cut into slabs and stacked and turned so whey drains and acid builds. This is cheddaring. Once the curd reaches the right acidity and has a firm, slightly stretchy feel, it's milled into small pieces.

Many beginners shorten this stage to save time, and the result is bland, wet curds with little squeak. Take the time.

Salt and finish

Salt the milled curds by sprinkling and tossing gently, usually in a couple of additions. Salt pulls out whey and sets the flavor. Then rest and drain the curds in a colander for a short while, but don't press them into a block.

Taste one. It should be mildly salty, milky and tangy, and it should squeak.

Keeping the squeak

The squeak comes from fresh protein structure rubbing on tooth enamel, and it fades as the cheese ages and moisture shifts. Keep curds at cool room temperature the day they're made, or refrigerated in a loosely covered container for a short time. Many people say curds squeak best when they've sat at room temperature for a bit before serving. Refrigeration firms them up and mutes the squeak, though a short rest at room temperature can bring some of it back.

Don't freeze curds if you want squeak. Texture suffers.

Why curds go wrong

Rubbery, dry curds usually mean the cook was too hot or too long. Soft, soggy ones mean not enough acid development or not enough salt. Curds that taste flat have too little salt or not enough time in the cheddaring stage. Curds that melt into a mat in gravy were probably made from a mozzarella-style process or have too much moisture.

Keep a log of each batch with temperatures, times and how the curd felt. Squeak is a good test, but also try a few curds in hot gravy. A good curd softens at the edges and keeps its center.

Also check your milk. Milk from some herds and seasons makes firmer curd than milk from others, so recipes may need small adjustments through the year.

Selling curds fresh

If you plan to sell curds, plan your make schedule around delivery. Many sellers make curds the morning of a market or restaurant delivery. Label them with the make date and advise customers to eat them soon. Fresh is the whole point.

Serving and selling

For poutine, serve warm fries topped with curds and hot gravy, in that order, and eat fast. The heat should soften the curds without turning them into a puddle.

If you sell fresh curds, treat them as a perishable dairy product. You'll need proper facility licensing, labeling and temperature control. Ask your state dairy regulator and review the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service. For small processors, the University of Wisconsin farm resources and Penn State Extension offer cheesemaking help, and the Agricultural Marketing Resource Center covers value-added marketing.

If the curds stop squeaking, they're still good on a burger. They're just not poutine anymore.