How do I make cheese spread?
Soft, spreadable, and reliably smooth
LANCASTER, Pennsylvania — You make cheese spread by blending cheese with a little liquid and a smooth-making ingredient, then warming it just enough to bring it together and chilling it in a covered container. Two paths work. The quick one is a cultured or fresh cheese blended with herbs and a splash of milk or cream. The more involved one melts aged cheese with an emulsifying salt like sodium citrate, which gives you a smooth, sliceable-to-spreadable result without graininess. Which path you choose depends on your cheese and your plan for selling it, since a sold product has to meet food rules.
The simple route: fresh cheese spread
Start with a soft cheese such as chevre, cream cheese, cottage cheese or fromage blanc. Beat it in a bowl or food processor with a bit of salt and something to loosen it, like cream or whey. Add chopped herbs, garlic, peppers or honey.
Keep it cold and keep it short. Fresh spreads have high moisture and low acidity compared to aged cheese, so they spoil faster. Use clean tools and store in the refrigerator, and eat within a few days to a week, or whatever your safe handling plan says.
The melted route: aged cheese spread
Grate cheddar, Colby or Swiss. Heat a little liquid, such as milk, beer or water, in a pan with a pinch of sodium citrate. Stir in the cheese a handful at a time over low heat until smooth. Pour into a clean container and chill.
Without an emulsifier, aged cheese often turns stringy or oily when melted and then blended. Sodium citrate keeps the proteins and fat from separating. Follow a tested recipe for amounts rather than guessing.
Texture and flavor tweaks
If it's too stiff, add liquid a spoonful at a time. If it's too loose, chill it longer or add more grated cheese. Sharp aged cheese gives the strongest flavor, and mild young cheese gives the creamiest texture, so many makers blend the two.
Acid helps flavor but can curdle a sauce. Add lemon, vinegar or pickled ingredients at the end and in small amounts, then taste.
Season with care. Salt, smoke, cayenne and herbs all concentrate in a cold spread, so what tastes right warm may taste muted after a night in the fridge.
Storage and safety
Cheese spread is a moist, ready-to-eat food. Store it in a clean, tight container, label it with the date made, and keep it cold. Don't double-dip, and don't leave it on the counter for a long afternoon. If it smells sour or looks slimy or moldy, toss it.
Selling spreads is a different matter from sharing them. A product with added ingredients and heat treatment may fall under different rules than plain cheese, and it must be labeled properly. Check with your state food regulator and read up at USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.
Flavors that work
Cheese spread is forgiving of experiments, as long as you keep things cold and clean. Cheddar spread takes well to mustard, hot peppers, beer and smoked paprika. Fresh chevre spread is good with roasted garlic, chives, honey or dried fruit. Blue cheese spread likes walnuts and a little cream.
Add dry spices and herbs sparingly, since they swell as the spread sits. Fresh garlic and onion can develop harsh flavor and spoil faster than dried versions, so keep batches small if you use them.
Let the finished spread rest in the fridge overnight before judging it. The flavors blend, the texture firms up and you'll know whether it needs more salt or acid. Write the recipe down while you remember what you did.
Packaging spread
Pack spread into clean jars or tubs while it's still warm if it was melted, then cool quickly in the refrigerator. Leave a small headspace. Label with the date and ingredients. Don't reuse containers that held other foods unless they've been properly washed and sanitized.
Where to learn more
For small-scale food processing advice, see Penn State Extension and Cornell Small Farms. For help thinking about pricing and marketing a value-added farm product, the Agricultural Marketing Resource Center and the Small Business Administration's business plan guide are useful.
The nice thing about cheese spread is that it forgives the wheel that didn't turn out. It also forgives the cracker shortage.