How do I make cream cheese from scratch?
Cream, culture and a long drain
PETALUMA, California — Cream cheese is made from cream or a mix of milk and cream, cultured with a mesophilic starter, set slowly, drained and salted. It's a soft, spreadable, mildly tangy cheese, and it takes about a day of waiting but very little work. The longer you drain, the thicker it gets. Here's the method, how to choose milk and cream, and how to fix common problems like grainy texture or a thin, runny finish, so your first batch ends up on a bagel and not in the compost.
Milk, cream and culture
For classic cream cheese, use heavy cream or a blend of cream and whole milk. Fat content around ten to twelve percent in the mix gives a good texture, and richer blends make a richer cheese. Use pasteurized, non-ultra-pasteurized dairy if you can, since ultra-pasteurized cream sets poorly.
Add a mesophilic culture, and many recipes include a drop of rennet. Without rennet the set is purely acid and takes longer. Follow your culture's instructions, and measure the rennet carefully, since a tiny amount is all you need and too much makes the cheese rubbery. Dilute it in cool, non-chlorinated water before adding.
Ripen the mix
Warm the cream mixture to about 72 to 75 degrees F. Sprinkle culture over the surface, let it rehydrate, then stir gently. Add diluted rennet if using, stir, cover and leave at room temperature for twelve to eighteen hours, or until it sets like soft yogurt with a bit of whey on top.
Don't disturb it while setting. A sour but clean smell is normal. Pink, orange or fuzzy growth means start over. A cooler kitchen takes longer, and a warmer one takes less time and sours more, so adjust the clock to the room.
Drain in cloth
Ladle the set curd into a cloth-lined colander or a bag of butter muslin. Hang or set in the fridge to drain. Four to six hours gives a soft cheese. Overnight gives a thick spread. Drain longer for firm cream cheese, which cuts into blocks.
Stir the curd and scrape the sides occasionally, so draining stays even. Don't squeeze hard, since that makes the cheese grainy and loses fat. If you want a smoother, thicker result, you can also drain in the refrigerator for a longer time rather than hurrying it by pressing.
Salt and smooth it out
Mix in salt to taste, often around half a teaspoon per pound. A hand blender or food processor can smooth the texture. Add herbs, garlic, chives or fruit after that. Add salt in small amounts, tasting as you go, since drained curd tastes saltier once it's cold.
Homemade cream cheese lacks the stabilizers of commercial brands, so it's softer and a bit more perishable. Store it cold in a clean container and use it within about a week. If it smells off, shows mold or turns watery and sour, discard it.
Troubleshoot and learn
Grainy cheese means curd was broken too early or squeezed too hard. Thin cheese just needs more draining. Sour cheese may have fermented too long or at too warm a temperature. A cheese that won't set at all may have come from ultra-pasteurized dairy or weak culture, so check dates and storage.
Use the whey for baking, pancakes or smoothies, or feed it to animals in small amounts. For selling, state licensing applies, along with labeling and inspection rules. See Penn State Extension, eXtension, Cornell Small Farms and AgMRC.
If you want to flavor cream cheese for sale, keep it simple and keep it cold. Fresh herbs, garlic and fruit add moisture and can shorten shelf life, so make flavored versions in small batches and label them with a use-by guide approved by your state regulator. Plain cream cheese holds up better, and you can let customers add their own flavor at home.
Cream cheese is the one cheese where you mostly stand back. It's good practice for people who can't stop stirring.