How do I make feta at home?
Brined white cheese, step by step
MARSHFIELD, Wisconsin — Feta is one of the more forgiving cheeses for a farm kitchen. It's a brine-cured white cheese made with a mesophilic culture and rennet, drained in a cloth or mold, cut into blocks, salted and then aged in brine in the refrigerator. Traditional feta uses sheep or goat milk, but cow milk works fine and gives a milder, firmer cheese. You don't need a cave or a press. You need clean equipment, a thermometer you trust, a few days of work spread over a weekend, and a few weeks of patience while the brine does its job. Here's the process and the places where beginners usually slip.
Gather milk, culture and rennet
Start with a gallon or two of fresh, pasteurized milk that isn't ultra-pasteurized, since ultra-pasteurized milk often fails to set a firm curd. You'll need a mesophilic starter culture, liquid or tablet rennet, and calcium chloride if you're using store-bought milk, because processing can weaken the curd. Dilute rennet in cool, non-chlorinated water just before adding it, and use it right away.
Goat milk gives a tangy, crumbly feta, and sheep milk a rich, creamy one. If you milk your own animals, know that selling the cheese brings state licensing rules, and that raw milk handling is regulated differently from pasteurized. Home use is your own call; commercial sale is not.
Make the curd
Warm the milk to around 86 degrees F, sprinkle the culture on top, let it rehydrate for a couple of minutes, and stir gently. Hold the milk at temperature for about an hour so acid starts to build. Add calcium chloride if your recipe calls for it, then stir in the rennet with an up-and-down motion for about a minute and stop the milk moving completely.
Let it set until you get a clean break, which usually takes somewhere around 45 minutes to an hour. Slide a clean knife in at an angle and lift. If the curd splits cleanly and clear whey fills the gap, you're ready. If it's soft and cloudy, wait ten more minutes and check again. Moving the pot during the set is the surest way to get a weak curd.
Cut, rest and drain
Cut the curd into roughly half-inch cubes, then let the pieces rest in the whey for several minutes so they firm slightly. Stir very gently for a few minutes more. Smaller cubes give a drier cheese, so match the size to the texture you want.
Ladle the curd into a cloth-lined colander or a draining mold. Many makers tie it into a bag and hang it for several hours, until it holds together but still feels moist. If you're using a mold, flip the mass now and then so both sides drain evenly. Collect the whey, because you may want a cup of it for the brine.
Salt and brine
Cut the drained cheese into blocks that fit your container. Salt the surface lightly and rest the pieces at cool room temperature for about a day. That firms the outside and starts pulling out moisture.
Next, make brine with non-iodized salt in cooled boiled water. Many recipes use a salt level somewhere around eight to ten percent by weight, but follow your specific recipe. A splash of whey in the brine and a bit of calcium chloride help protect the cheese surface. Submerge the blocks, weight them if they float, and keep the container in the fridge.
Age, taste and troubleshoot
Feta needs at least a few weeks in brine for flavor and texture to settle in. Taste a piece after a week, then again later, and write down what you notice. Too salty? Soak a piece in plain cool water for a short while before eating.
If the cheese turns slimy or the brine smells bad, discard it and clean the container. A thin film on the brine surface can be wiped off with a clean cloth dipped in brine, and a heavily clouded brine should be replaced. Keep everything cold. For more background, check eXtension, Penn State Extension, and the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service if you want to sell what you make.
Feta rewards boring consistency. Same milk, same timing, same brine. Your goat will not respect that, but your cheese will.