How do I make goat milk butter?

Pale, soft and worth the cream

SPARTA, Wisconsin — Goat milk butter is made the same way as any butter: separate the cream, ripen it if you like, churn it until the fat clumps, drain the buttermilk, wash the butter, and work in salt. Two things make goat butter different. It is bright white because goat milk lacks the carotene that colors cow butter yellow, and the cream is harder to separate because goat fat globules are small and stay suspended in the milk. Below is how to get the cream, churn it, finish the butter and what to watch if you plan to sell it.

Separate the cream

Because of the small fat globules, goat milk cream rises slowly and not very cleanly. The easiest and most reliable way is a mechanical cream separator, which spins cream from the milk. Without one, let fresh milk stand in the refrigerator for a day or two in a wide, shallow container and skim the top, but expect a smaller, less reliable harvest.

Goat cream is milder than many expect, but the quality of the milk shows through. Chill milk fast after milking and handle it cleanly, since off flavors carry into butter.

Ripen or not

Sweet cream butter comes from churning cream right away, and it keeps a delicate flavor. Cultured butter comes from adding a bit of live culture, such as cultured buttermilk or a mesophilic starter, to the cream and letting it sit at room temperature for about a day. Cultured butter has a tangier, more complex flavor and many people prefer it.

If you plan to sell, check whether your state requires pasteurizing the cream. Pasteurize it and then cool before culturing.

Churn

Bring the cream to a cool temperature, roughly in the 50s F, because cream that is too warm gives greasy butter and cream that is too cold takes forever. Pour it into a stand mixer, food processor, jar or churn. The cream whips, then turns grainy, then suddenly separates into butter grains and thin buttermilk. Stop when the grains are about the size of small peas.

A jar and some arm strength works for small batches. Fill it about halfway and shake.

Wash, salt and shape

Drain the buttermilk, which you can use in baking or drinking, and rinse the butter in cold water, pressing and folding until the water runs clear. Leftover buttermilk spoils the butter quickly, so be thorough. Work in salt if you want salted butter, usually a modest pinch per pound, or leave it plain. Press the butter into a mold, roll it in parchment or shape it with paddles.

Wrap well and store cold; fresh butter keeps for a couple of weeks refrigerated, and longer frozen.

Troubleshoot and sell with care

Butter is a regulated dairy product, and selling it normally requires a licensed facility and compliant labeling. Ask your state agriculture department before selling. The Agricultural Marketing Resource Center has value-added dairy information, ATTRA offers goat production resources, and eXtension can connect you with classes. The USDA AMS local food resources help with market ideas.

Goat butter is white, soft and mild, and it stands out on a table of yellow butter. It also has the dubious distinction of using the part of the milk that goats keep hidden.