How do I make halloumi that holds shape?
Heat the curd, cook it in whey
NICOSIA, Nebraska — Halloumi holds its shape because the curd is cooked and pressed before it's simmered in hot whey, which firms the protein, drives out moisture and keeps the cheese from melting into a puddle on the grill. The mistakes that make halloumi fall apart are usually the same few: too much acid, too little cooking, curd that was broken too small or pressed unevenly, and skipping the hot whey poach. Fix those and you'll have a squeaky block that browns instead of slumping.
Choose the milk and keep acid low
Traditional halloumi uses sheep or goat milk, or a blend, and cow's milk works well too. Use whole, pasteurized, non-UHT milk. Unlike most cheeses, halloumi is made with rennet and usually little or no acid-producing starter. Too much acid gives you a crumbly or melting cheese. Warm the milk to about 90 degrees Fahrenheit, add rennet, and let it set into a firm curd. Follow a trusted recipe for dose, and add calcium chloride only if your pasteurized milk produces a weak set.
Cut small and cook the curd
Cut the curd into pieces about the size of a pea or small bean, which releases whey and creates a firmer finished cheese. Heat slowly while stirring to around 105 to 115 degrees Fahrenheit, holding it until the curd feels firm and springy. Let it settle, then pour off some whey and keep it. You'll need that whey later. Packing the curd tight in a cloth-lined mold gives a clean, solid texture. A loose pack leaves gaps that become cracks.
Press, then poach in whey
Press the curd with moderate weight for an hour or so, flipping once. The block should hold together when you cut it into slabs. Now heat the reserved whey to a near-simmer, usually around 175 to 185 degrees Fahrenheit, and lower the slabs into the pot. The cheese will sink and then float as it cooks. When it floats and feels firm, it's done. This step is what sets halloumi's structure, so don't skip it or cut it short. Keep the heat steady and avoid a rolling boil, which toughens the outside.
Salt, fold and rest
Remove the cheese and drain it. Sprinkle with salt, and traditional makers add dried mint before folding the slab in half. Rest the cheese in the refrigerator for a day before eating. Store it in a salted brine if you won't eat it soon, which also helps the texture. Fresh halloumi is mild and squeaky; aged for a while in brine, it gets saltier and a little firmer.
Test it in the pan
Cut a slab about half an inch thick and fry or grill it over medium-high heat without oil. If it slumps, you probably used too much acid or cooked the curd too lightly. If it is rubbery and dry, you overcooked the curd or poached too long. Adjust one variable at a time and record it.
For more background on small-scale dairy processing, see ATTRA and your state's cooperative extension, such as Penn State Extension. If you plan to sell it, check licensing with your state agriculture department.
Storing and cooking halloumi
Once made, halloumi keeps best in its own brine. Mix salt with a little whey or water until it tastes like the sea, then submerge the cheese in a clean container in the refrigerator. For longer storage, some makers vacuum seal it or freeze it, though freezing slightly changes the texture. When you cook it, use a hot, dry pan or grill and don't crowd the slices, because steam keeps them pale. Rinse very salty slices briefly and pat them dry. If a slab still falls apart in the pan, compare it with your make sheet and change just one thing next time, either less starter, a longer cook or a longer poach. Changing three things at once teaches you nothing.
Halloumi is one of the few cheeses you can cook directly in the pan without regret. When yours comes off the grill with stripes and no puddle, you did it right.