How do I make sheep milk yogurt?
Thick, creamy and easy to set
JOHNSON, Vermont — Sheep milk yogurt is one of the easiest dairy products to make well, because the milk is naturally high in solids and sets thick and creamy without any additives. Heat the milk, cool it to culturing temperature, stir in a live yogurt culture, hold it warm for several hours, and chill. That is the whole method. The main challenge isn't the technique but the supply, since sheep give limited milk. Below is a step-by-step process with tips on temperature, timing and storage.
Gather your supplies
You need fresh sheep milk, a starter, either a few spoonfuls of plain live yogurt or a freeze-dried culture, a pot, a thermometer, clean jars, and a way to hold a steady warm temperature, such as a yogurt maker, an oven with the light on, or an insulated cooler with warm water. Sanitize jars and utensils.
Fresh milk gives the best flavor. If you use milk that was frozen, thaw it slowly in the refrigerator and stir it before use; the texture may be slightly grainy but still works for yogurt.
Heat and cool
- Heat the milk to around 180°F, stirring so it doesn't scorch, and hold it there for a short time. This firms the final texture.
- Cool to about 110°F, which is warm but not hot to the touch.
- Stir in the culture, following package directions for the amount, mixing thoroughly.
Because sheep milk is rich, it scorches easily, so use a heavy-bottomed pot or a water bath and stir gently.
Incubate
Pour the milk into jars or leave it in the pot, cover and keep at a steady warm temperature, roughly 105 to 112°F, for about 4 to 8 hours. Don't jostle it. Shorter times give a milder yogurt and longer times a tangier one. When it sets into a soft gel that pulls away from the side of the jar, move it to the refrigerator.
Chill for several hours before eating, as it firms further in the cold.
Strain for thicker styles
Sheep milk yogurt is already thick, but you can strain it for a Greek-style product or further for a spreadable labneh. Hang it in cloth over a bowl for several hours. Use the whey in baking or give it to pigs or poultry in reasonable amounts.
You can also flavor it with honey, fruit, herbs or garlic for savory dips. Add flavors after the set.
Storage, safety and selling
Store yogurt cold and use it within about a week or two, tasting before use. Keep a few spoonfuls of your batch to start the next one, though after many generations the culture may weaken and you may need a fresh starter.
If you want to sell yogurt, check with your state agriculture department about dairy processing licenses, pasteurization requirements and labeling. Expect to document each batch. The Sheep Industry Association can connect you with other dairy sheep producers, the Agricultural Marketing Resource Center has value-added dairy information, and ATTRA covers small ruminant enterprises. eXtension is a good place to find local workshops.
Because sheep milk supply is small, many producers make yogurt alongside cheese, using the same pasteurization setup. It's a quick-turnaround product that brings in money while wheels age. Once you've tasted it, you will understand why the ewes are so protective of the supply.