How do I make smoked cheese?

Cold smoking without melting a thing

WICHITA FALLS, Texas — You make smoked cheese by exposing firm, cool cheese to wood smoke at a temperature low enough that the cheese doesn't sweat or melt, usually below the point where fat starts to run. That's called cold smoking, and it's the usual method for cheddar, Gouda, Swiss and similar hard or semi-hard cheeses. The trick is smoke without heat. A smoker running hot will give you a puddle with a smoky smell. If you can keep the chamber cool and the smoke gentle, you get cheese with a deep flavor that develops after a rest in the fridge.

Pick the right cheese

Firm, lower-moisture cheeses hold up best. Cheddar, Gouda, Swiss, provolone, Monterey Jack and Colby are common choices. Soft, wet cheeses can be smoked but they're delicate and need more care.

Use a block that's been aged at least a little, since a very young, wet cheese will sweat. Cut it into pieces that are easy to handle, such as thick bars or smaller blocks, so more surface sees smoke. Put the cheese in the fridge before you start so it begins cold.

Set up cold smoke

You need a way to make smoke without much heat. Options include a smoke generator attached to a cabinet, a pellet tube, or a small pan of smoldering sawdust in a separate chamber so heat dissipates before it reaches the cheese. A cool day helps, and some people set up on a cold morning or put ice in a pan.

Keep the chamber temperature well below the point where the cheese softens. Many makers aim for the 70s°F or cooler, and some stay lower still. Put a thermometer next to the cheese, not on the wall of the smoker, and watch it.

Smoke time and rest

Smoke for roughly a half hour to a few hours, depending on how strong you like it and how heavy your smoke is. Lighter is easier to fix next time. Flip the cheese partway through so the smoke hits all sides.

When the cheese comes out, it will taste harsh and sharp. That's normal. Pat off any surface moisture, then wrap it loosely in parchment or paper and rest it in the refrigerator, often for a week or two. Mellowing is part of the process, so don't judge the batch the same day.

Food safety

Cold smoking isn't a kill step. Smoke doesn't sterilize anything. Start with cheese made from properly treated milk, handle it with clean gloves, and keep it cold before and after smoking. Don't leave cheese sitting in a warm chamber for long, and don't smoke in an enclosure that you can't clean.

If you plan to sell it, there are rules on facilities, labeling and sometimes added smoke ingredients. Check with your state dairy regulator and the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.

Choosing a smoking setup

You don't need a fancy rig. Many people build a cold smoker from a cardboard or wooden cabinet connected to a small firebox by a length of metal duct. The longer the duct, the cooler the smoke arrives. A cheap pellet tube inside a closed grill works too, as long as the grill stays cool.

Whatever you use, check the rules of the place where you cook. A cabinet near a barn or wood pile is a fire hazard, so keep it in the open, away from hay and dry grass. Keep a bucket of water or a hose close.

Also think about cleanup. Smoke leaves creosote and soot, so wipe the cabinet and racks after use, and keep cheese off surfaces that have held raw meat unless you've sanitized them thoroughly.

Where to get more help

Extension programs publish handy information on smoking and food handling. Try Penn State Extension and Cornell Small Farms for small-scale processing advice. For selling value-added products from the farm, the Agricultural Marketing Resource Center is a good starting point.

A last practical note: smoke what you can eat. Smoked cheese disappears from the fridge faster than regular cheese, and you'll want a second batch right away.