How do I manage commodity price risk?

Know your exposure, then pick tools

CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa — Manage commodity price risk by working out how much feed you need to buy and how much milk you'll sell, deciding how much price swing the farm can survive, and then using a mix of tools: forward contracts, futures and options, insurance products and good old budgeting. There's no single right tool. The right mix depends on your cash position, your lender's view and your appetite for stress.

You don't have to predict the market. You have to know what happens to your margin if prices move against you, and make sure that outcome isn't fatal.

Know your exposure

Start with a simple map. How much corn, soybean meal, byproducts and forage do you buy in a year? How much milk do you ship, and how is it priced? Which costs are fixed and which float? Work out your margin at several price scenarios, including a bad one. Spreadsheets from Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker and the Center for Farm Financial Management can help.

Then ask: at what feed price or milk price does this farm start losing money, and how long can we last? That's your risk limit. Talk with your lender, since they care about the same number.

Forward contracts and buying ahead

The simplest tool is to lock in feed prices with suppliers through forward contracts, covering part of expected needs. You can also buy and store ahead if you have the space, though storage costs and shrink matter. Don't lock in everything. Many farms cover a portion of needs and leave the rest open, then add more at set intervals, so no single day decides the year.

Read the contract carefully. Look at delivery windows, quality specs, price basis and what happens if either side can't perform. A separate article covers feed contracts in more detail.

Futures and options

Hedging with futures or options can protect against price moves, though it adds complexity: margin accounts, basis risk and the need to understand the contract. Options can set a price ceiling or floor at a known cost, while futures lock a price but can create margin calls. Both require education and a broker you trust. If you're new, start small and talk with your lender and an educator. The farmdoc daily site offers analysis on risk management and hedging basics.

Whatever tools you choose, write down the hedge ratio you're aiming for and review it with a person who isn't selling you anything. A lender, an extension educator or an accountant who knows your books can tell you when a position has grown beyond what the farm can carry, which is easier to hear before the market moves than after.

Don't use these tools to speculate. Hedging is about reducing risk, not about guessing. If a position keeps you up at night, it's too big.

Insurance and federal programs

USDA offers risk management programs related to dairy margins and revenue, and details change over time. The Farm Service Agency administers programs like margin protection for dairy, and the Risk Management Agency oversees insurance products, including those for dairy revenue and margins. Enrollment periods, coverage levels and costs vary, so go to those sites or your local office for current rules. Don't rely on someone's memory of last year's terms.

Ask your agent or FSA office what's available in your state and what the deadlines are. Missing a sign-up window is the most common and most avoidable mistake.

Use information, not tips

Follow market information from neutral sources. The AMS Market News reports publish prices for feed, hay and dairy products, and the Economic Research Service publishes data and outlook material. Check current figures there instead of using numbers you saw in an article.

Set a plan before volatility hits. Write down when you'll buy, how much, what triggers a review and who decides. Rules written in a calm week help in a panic week.

  1. Calculate feed needs and milk sales for the year.
  2. Estimate margin under good, normal and bad prices.
  3. Set the maximum loss you can accept.
  4. Cover part of feed needs in stages.
  5. Check federal programs and insurance, and note deadlines.
  6. Use hedging tools only after you understand them.
  7. Review the plan with your lender and advisors quarterly.

Risk management isn't about being right. It's about staying in business when you're wrong.