How do I price artisan cheese?
Cost, yield, and what buyers will pay
HUDSON, New York — You price artisan cheese by working out the real cost of making a pound of it, adding a margin that covers your labor and overhead, and then checking the number against what your customers will actually pay. Many first-time makers price from the market down and then discover they're paid less than minimum wage. Start with your cost per pound, based on milk, yield, labor, aging losses and packaging. Then choose a price that works across retail, wholesale and shipping.
Know your yield
Yield is how many pounds of cheese you get from a given amount of milk, and it varies by cheese style and milk quality. Soft, wet cheeses yield more per gallon, and hard aged cheeses yield less. Track yield on every make, using a scale, and average over several batches.
Your milk cost per pound of cheese is milk cost divided by the pounds produced. If you produce your own milk, don't treat it as free. Value it at what you could sell it for.
Add every cost
- Milk: purchased or the value of your own.
- Ingredients: cultures, rennet, salt, wax.
- Labor: make time, cleaning, turning, packing, selling.
- Aging shrink: weight lost to evaporation and rind trimming.
- Packaging and labels.
- Overhead: utilities, licenses, insurance, equipment, rent.
- Waste: batches that don't make it.
Many makers forget aging shrink and labor. Both can be large. Use the Small Business Administration's business plan guide to organize numbers.
Price by channel
Direct sales at a farmers market or farm store bring the highest price per pound, but cost you selling time. Wholesale to shops and restaurants pays less, often with the retailer adding their own markup. Shipping adds cost and risk.
Work backward from retail. If a shop needs to mark your cheese up, what wholesale price leaves you a profit? If it doesn't, your retail price may need to rise or your costs fall.
Check the market
Look at what similar cheeses sell for locally, but don't copy. A younger, simpler cheese may sell for less than an aged specialty wheel. Sample your cheese, listen to customers and test small price changes. For market information, see the Agricultural Marketing Resource Center and Dairy Markets. For current dairy commodity information, check the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service market news.
Raising prices without losing customers
If your numbers say you must charge more, change the price in steps and explain the value. Tell customers about the milk, the aging and the labor. People who buy artisan cheese often care about those details.
Consider selling a mix of products. A lower-priced young cheese brings in new buyers and cash flow. A premium aged wheel carries margin. Bundle cheeses for gifts at a higher total price.
Revisit your numbers a few times a year. Milk, packaging and labor costs move, and a price that worked last season might not work now. A simple spreadsheet is enough.
Don't forget your time
Most cheesemakers underpay themselves. Track hours for a full make cycle, including cleanup, turning, packing, paperwork and markets. Put a fair hourly rate on those hours and add it to the cost per pound. If the final price looks too high for your market, the answer may be to change your product mix or find efficiencies, not to work for nothing.
Sample pricing worksheet
Put the numbers on one page. Write milk cost per pound of cheese, then add ingredients, packaging, labor hours times your hourly rate, aging shrink, overhead per pound and a waste allowance. The total is your break-even. Add a profit margin on top to get the lowest wholesale price you should accept. Then compare retail price to wholesale price and see what the shop's margin would be. If any step surprises you, you've found something to fix.
Taxes and records
Keep records of costs and sales. The IRS Publication 225 is the farmer's tax guide, and a tax professional can tell you how value-added sales are treated. Review your numbers regularly, since milk and labor costs move.
The goal is a price that pays for your cheese and your time. The market usually pays what it's offered, so offer fairly.