How do I read a bull proof?
Learn the columns before the hype
BARABOO, Wisconsin — A bull proof is a summary of what a sire is expected to pass on to his daughters, expressed as predicted transmitting ability for each trait and combined into index values. Reading one well means knowing what each number means, how reliable it is, and which traits matter on your farm. Most proofs look intimidating at first, but they follow a pattern. This article explains the common parts of a proof and the checks to run before you buy a straw.
Know the basic terms
Predicted transmitting ability (PTA) estimates how a bull's daughters will perform compared with a baseline group, with the number showing the expected difference in the trait. A positive number for a trait like milk means higher expected yield; for traits like somatic cell score, lower is generally better, which is why you have to read each trait's direction carefully. Different breeds and countries use different baselines, so don't compare numbers across breeds without checking.
Find the reliability figure
Reliability, usually shown as a percentage, indicates how much confidence you can place in a number. A high reliability means the estimate is unlikely to shift. A low reliability, as with a young bull, means it could move up or down. Don't ignore it. When two bulls look similar, the one with higher reliability carries less risk.
Understand genomic versus daughter-proven
Many bulls are evaluated first on genomics, meaning DNA information combined with pedigree. These genomic proofs come out before any daughters are milking, and their reliability is lower than for a bull with a large daughter group. As daughters enter the herd, the proof updates with real data. Ask your AI company whether a bull is genomic, proven or both.
Look at the index and the individual traits
An index such as a net merit or other economic index combines many traits into one number. It's a useful first filter. Then check traits that matter most to you: production components, fertility, calving ease, health traits, productive life, feet and legs, udder traits and body size. A single high index can hide a weak trait that bothers your herd.
Find the explanation of each trait in your breed association's or evaluation agency's documentation, since definitions and scales differ between countries and traits.
Check type and calving traits
Type traits describe conformation, like udder depth, teat placement, feet, legs and rump angle. Calving traits describe how easily a bull's calves are born, and how likely stillbirth is. If you breed heifers, calving ease for sire matters a lot. Look at the specific calving trait described by your evaluation agency, and learn whether it applies to heifers, cows or both.
Compare in context
Place a bull's numbers alongside others on your shortlist. Check how his proof has changed over successive evaluations, since big swings suggest low reliability. Ask your AI company for a mating program that considers relationships among your cows and avoids inbreeding.
Where to find definitions and help
Evaluation agencies and breed associations publish glossaries and trait descriptions, and your AI company representative can explain them. The U.S. Dairy site gives industry background, eXtension provides educational material, and Penn State Extension has dairy management articles. For market and economic context, try the Dairy Markets site.
Last thought: a proof sheet is a forecast, not a promise. Daughters are born into your barn, your feed and your management, and no number tells them how to behave.