How do I reduce feed costs without losing milk?

Cut waste before you cut nutrition

FORT COLLINS, Colorado — The safest way to lower feed cost without losing milk is to attack waste and mismatches first and nutrition last. Shrink, sorting, overfeeding, poor forage quality and one-size-fits-all rations quietly cost more than most herds realize. Once those are tight, you can look at cheaper ingredients and fine-tuning. Cutting feed quality across the board usually just moves the cost from the feed bill to the milk check.

Measure where feed goes

Start by weighing what's fed and what's refused. Calculate dry matter intake and cost per cow per day by pen. Look at shrink in storage and at the bunk. Some farms find several percent of their feed disappearing between the field and the cow. That's money you can find without touching the ration.

Fix forage first

Forage is usually your cheapest source of nutrients. Better harvest timing, tight packing, good covering and careful feed-out raise quality and cut loss. Test forage so you aren't buying protein or energy the forage already supplies. A cheap, mediocre forage may cost more when you buy extra grain to make up for it.

Don't overfeed

Feeding protein, minerals or energy above the requirement wastes money. Check milk urea nitrogen, body condition and component yield. Group cows by stage and production so late-lactation cows aren't fed a high-cow ration. Most farms find savings from grouping, since the ration for each group can be matched more closely.

Shop for nutrients, not ingredients

Compare ingredients on cost per unit of the nutrient you need, such as metabolizable protein or net energy, not cost per ton. Byproducts, local grains and forages can fit, but check delivered cost, storage, shrink and variability. Recheck your nutritionist's ingredient list a few times a year as prices move.

For current commodity information, see USDA AMS Market News and Dairy Markets, and for the arithmetic use tools from the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker. I've left out prices because they change faster than articles.

Watch income over feed cost

Pounds of milk isn't the target. Income over feed cost is. Sometimes cutting a feed saves more than the milk lost, sometimes it loses more. Calculate using your own milk price and component yields. Minnesota's Center for Farm Financial Management and farmdoc daily have economic tools and analysis.

Change one thing at a time

Make cuts in small steps, with a clear measure, such as milk, components, intake, manure and body condition. If milk drops, step back. Keep your nutritionist involved, since they can advise on what to trim safely and what to leave. Penn State Extension has resources on feed cost management.

Revisit regularly

Feed markets change, and what was cheap last spring may not be now. Build a habit of reviewing ration cost every few months and whenever you open a new forage. Spending an afternoon with the feed records is rarely wasted, even if it's less fun than an auction.