How do I start making cheese at home?

Start small, clean, and patient

MADISON, Wisconsin — Start with one gallon of store-bought or fresh milk, a stainless steel pot, a thermometer you trust, a long knife, and a clean kitchen. Make a fresh cheese first, something like ricotta or a simple acid-set cheese, because it forgives mistakes and gives you a finished product in an afternoon. Once you can hit a target temperature and cut a curd without panic, move on to a cultured cheese with rennet. Cheesemaking is mostly three things: controlling temperature, controlling acid, and keeping the wrong bacteria out. Everything else is detail.

Gather a short equipment list

You don't need a creamery. A non-reactive pot (stainless steel, not aluminum or cast iron) with a lid is the main purchase. Add a dairy thermometer that reads in one-degree steps, a long-bladed knife for cutting curd, a slotted spoon or skimmer, a colander, and butter muslin or fine cheesecloth. A measuring spoon set that goes down to a quarter teaspoon matters more than people expect, since cultures and rennet are used in tiny amounts.

For a first hard cheese you'll eventually want a press, a few molds, and a place to age. Skip those at the start. Buy them only after you know you'll keep doing this, which, fair warning, most people do.

Pick a first recipe that matches your milk

Fresh cheeses forgive loose technique. Ricotta, paneer, and queso fresco are made by heating milk and adding acid, and they need no special cultures. A soft chevre-style or farmer-style cheese uses a mesophilic culture and a drop of rennet, and it teaches you how a curd behaves. Mozzarella is a good third project once you've handled curd a few times.

Whatever you pick, read the whole recipe twice before you warm the milk. Lay out every tool beforehand. Timing in cheesemaking is set by the milk, not by your schedule, so clear the afternoon.

Sanitation does most of the work

Clean and sanitize every surface and tool that touches milk or curd. Wash with hot soapy water, rinse well, then use a food-safe sanitizer according to its label, or boil small tools. A stray spoiler organism can ruin a vat just as easily as a wrong temperature. Wash your hands, tie back long hair, and keep pets out of the kitchen.

Keep a notebook. Write down the milk source, the volume, the culture, the rennet amount, the times, and what the cheese tasted like later. When batch seven is better than batch six, you'll want to know why.

Think about milk safety and local rules

Pasteurized milk is the safest starting point. Avoid ultra-pasteurized milk, which often fails to set a firm curd, and check the label for "ultra-pasteurized" before you buy. If you have your own cow, goat, or sheep, understand that raw milk carries real risk for soft, young cheese, and the federal rule for raw-milk cheese in the US involves aging it before sale. The FDA and the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service publish food safety guidance, and your state department of agriculture sets rules on selling any dairy product. If selling is ever on your mind, check those rules before the first customer, not after.

Where to learn more

Cooperative Extension offices run dairy and food-safety programs, and eXtension collects research-based material from many universities. The University of Wisconsin farm extension site is a good place to look for dairy information, and the National Agricultural Library can point you to published research. Your county extension office may also know of local cheesemaking classes or a guild that meets nearby.

Common beginner mistakes

Most first-batch failures come from the same short list. Milk that was ultra-pasteurized, a thermometer that reads wrong, and rennet stirred in too vigorously account for a lot of grief. Beginners also tend to cut the curd too early because they're nervous, which wastes yield and leaves a mushy cheese. Wait for a clean break, then cut.

Another trap is changing three things at once. If a batch comes out dry, you won't know whether it was the heat, the culture, or the pressing. Change one variable per batch. Also resist the urge to buy gear before you need it. A pot, a thermometer, and cloth will carry you through your first dozen batches.

Using the whey

Every batch leaves you with whey, often most of the volume you started with. Don't treat it as waste. Whey can go into bread, soup, or cooking water for grains, and some people feed small amounts to poultry or hogs. Ask your extension office or veterinarian before feeding it to animals. Never dump large volumes on the ground or into a septic system, since whey is rich in organic matter and can foul a drain field or stream.

Your first month

  1. Make ricotta or paneer in week one.
  2. Make a cultured soft cheese in week two.
  3. Try mozzarella in week three.
  4. In week four, write down what went wrong and fix one thing.

Your first cheese will probably be a little rubbery or a little crumbly. Eat it anyway. Cheese that looks rough still tastes like cheese, and your family will forgive a lot of curds.