How do I track processing costs?
Know what a gallon really costs
LEXINGTON, Kentucky — Track processing costs by splitting them into milk or ingredients, direct labor, packaging, utilities and overhead, then dividing by what you actually produce to get a cost per unit. Many small processors know what they pay for milk and guess at everything else. The guess is usually low.
Here's a step-by-step approach that works with a notebook or a spreadsheet.
Separate direct costs from overhead
Direct costs go up and down with production: milk or cream, cultures, rennet, salt, flavorings, packaging, labels, and the labor hours spent on each batch. Overhead stays roughly the same: rent or mortgage, insurance, licenses, equipment payments, repairs, office costs and your regulatory fees. Utilities sit in between, since steam, hot water, refrigeration and cleaning chemicals scale with production but also run when you're idle. List each category and pull the last several months of records. Don't forget your own pay; if you're not counting your labor, you're subsidizing your customers.
Calculate yield, not just volume
Yield is what you get out of what you put in. For cheese, that's pounds of finished product per hundred pounds of milk; for yogurt or bottled milk, it's usable units after losses. Record input, output, and waste for each batch. Yield varies with milk composition, make procedure and handling, so track it per recipe over time. A small yield drop can wipe out a margin. Weigh and measure, don't estimate. Your extension dairy specialist can help interpret differences in yield, and Extension is a good way to find one.
Assign labor and overhead fairly
Time a few batches from start to finish, including setup, cleaning and packing. Multiply by your wage cost, including payroll taxes and benefits. Then allocate overhead. A simple way is to divide monthly overhead by the pounds or units produced that month, then add that to each product. Heavier, slower products, such as aged cheese, tie up space and cash, so consider a charge for the time they occupy the room. Review the method with your accountant; IRS Publication 225 covers farm expense treatment, though processing operations may have different rules.
Build a batch cost sheet
For each batch record: date code, milk or ingredient amounts and costs, labor hours, packaging used, yield, waste and notes. Total it up and divide by finished units. Keep the sheets in one place and compare them. If cost per unit jumps, look for the reason: price of an input, a lower yield, extra cleaning, or a repair. Update ingredient prices when invoices change. Iowa State's ag decision maker has spreadsheets and guides that adapt to value-added costing.
Use the numbers
Compare cost per unit to your selling price by channel: retail, wholesale, direct. A product that looks profitable at retail may lose money when sold at the wholesale price. Look at which items make the most margin per hour of labor and per square foot of cooler space. Decide whether to reprice, change the recipe or cut a product. Review the figures every quarter and after any major price change in inputs.
Costing isn't glamorous, but the processors who do it know which products pay the bills. The ones who don't are working hard for an unknown result.