Choosing a Dairy Processor for Your Milk
What to compare before you sign a contract
NEW ULM, Minnesota — Picking who buys your milk is one of the biggest business decisions on a dairy, and it's often made on a handshake and a hauling route. The best processor for you isn't automatically the one that quotes the highest price. It's the one whose pay, pickup and terms leave you with the most money and the fewest surprises.
Your choices depend heavily on where you farm. In some places you'll have several buyers, in others only one. Either way, learn the terms before you commit.
Understand the types of buyers
Milk buyers generally fall into a few groups. Cooperatives are owned by their farmer members and typically market milk on their behalf, sometimes to their own plants and sometimes to others. Proprietary processors are companies that buy milk directly from farms. Some farms sell to small local plants or process their own milk. Each type has different obligations, membership rules and ways of sharing in profit.
Ask how each buyer treats members or suppliers when milk is in surplus. That's when differences between buyers show up fast: some limit volume, some pay lower prices for extra milk, and some stop picking up on certain days.
Learn how milk is priced
Milk pricing in much of the country is tied to federal milk marketing orders, which set minimum prices processors regulated by the order must pay for milk based on how it's used. The USDA Agricultural Marketing Service administers these orders and publishes information on how they work and where each order applies. Some states, such as California, run their own pricing system, so check your state's rules.
Minimum prices are only part of what you receive. Premiums, deductions and charges change what lands in your check, and these differ by buyer. Ask for a sample milk statement and have the buyer explain every line.
Questions to ask every buyer
Take a written list into every conversation:
- How is my price calculated, including components, quality premiums and volume adjustments?
- What deductions apply: hauling, promotion, equity retains, membership fees?
- What are the quality standards, and what happens if I miss one?
- How often is milk picked up, and does the hauler skip days?
- Will you take more milk if I expand, and what if I downsize?
- How are payments timed, and what protections exist if the buyer fails?
- What are the terms for leaving, and is there a notice period?
Get the answers in writing. If a buyer won't put terms on paper, assume the terms could change.
Check quality requirements and premiums
Buyers measure milk for components, somatic cell count, bacteria count and antibiotic residues. Premiums for high quality can add up, and penalties can sting. Ask what thresholds the buyer uses and how they're tested. The National Mastitis Council has practical guidance on udder health and milk quality that can help you meet them.
Make sure you know the process for a failed test. Who gets notified, how fast, and what's the procedure for dumping or rechecking? A good buyer's field representative will talk you through it before it happens.
Read the contract carefully
If you're offered a written agreement, read all of it, including the fine print on terms, exclusivity, deductions and termination. Have your lawyer or lender review it before signing, particularly if it ties you to a long commitment or involves equity in a cooperative. The National Agricultural Law Center publishes plain-language material on agricultural law that can help you understand contract concepts, though it doesn't replace advice from your own attorney.
The National Farmers Union and other producer organizations also follow dairy market policy and can tell you what other farmers in your region are experiencing.
Think about the long run
A buyer that looks reliable today may change hands, close a plant or cut routes. Consider how dependent the processor is on a single product or customer. Talk to other farmers who ship to the same buyer and ask how it treated them in a tough year. That's the best test you'll get.
Keep a second option alive if you can: a conversation with another buyer, even if you aren't switching. And keep records of your milk production and quality so that you're ready to negotiate or to move.
Market information is available from Dairy Markets and USDA reports, and you should look up current numbers there rather than rely on hearsay. A processor choice is a long relationship, so go in with your eyes open and your questions written down.
