How do I evaluate a creamery acquisition?

Buy the cheese, the permits and the people

FORT COLLINS, Colorado — You evaluate a creamery acquisition by looking past the asking price to what you're really buying: equipment, licenses, recipes, customers, milk supply, the building and the people who make it all work. Then you test each one against the books and against the rules. The price is the last thing to settle, not the first. A good deal on a plant with a shaky milk contract or an expired permit isn't a good deal.

Get an accountant, an attorney and a food safety professional on your side early. Each one catches things the others won't.

Start with the financials

Ask for several years of profit and loss statements, tax returns, balance sheets, sales by product and customer, and a list of debts and leases. Compare the numbers across sources: tax returns, bank deposits and books should roughly tell the same story. Look at margins by product, trends in sales, seasonality, owner pay and any expenses the owner runs through the business. Ask what the real profit would be with a fair manager's salary included.

Check whether sales depend on a few big customers. Losing one account shouldn't sink the business.

Inspect the plant and equipment

Hire someone who knows dairy equipment to look over vats, pasteurizers, coolers, compressors, boilers, piping and floors. Check age, condition, maintenance records and replacement needs. Ask what's owned and what's leased or financed. Look at the building too: roof, drains, ventilation, walls, utilities and capacity. Deferred maintenance is a hidden cost.

Ask about capacity: how much more could the plant make without major spending?

Check licenses, inspections and food safety

Ask for the plant's licenses, inspection reports, corrective action records, food safety plan, audit results, recall history and complaint logs. Contact the regulator to learn whether permits transfer to a new owner or have to be reissued, and how long that takes. Environmental compliance matters too: wastewater, whey disposal and any permits for them. A hidden violation becomes your violation on closing day.

Review the label files and formulas for compliance, and check how raw milk or other special products are handled.

Look at milk supply, contracts and the brand

Where does the milk come from, and under what agreement? A cheese business without a reliable milk source has a gap at its center. Review supplier contracts, customer contracts, distribution agreements, leases, employment agreements and any licensing deals. Find out which ones can be assigned to a new owner and which end at sale. Check trademarks, domain names, recipes and social accounts, and make sure the seller actually owns them.

Talk to customers and staff, with the seller's permission, to see how the brand is regarded. Reputation is part of the value.

Understand the people and the transition

Cheesemakers often carry the real recipe in their heads. Ask how much of the process is written down, and whether the seller and key employees will stay on through a transition. A purchase agreement can include training time, a non-compete clause and consulting arrangements. Keep key staff by talking to them early and fairly.

Settle price and structure with advice

Valuation methods vary: multiples of earnings, asset value or a mix. Your accountant can explain the options. Think about how the deal is structured, either as an asset purchase or a stock purchase, and what that means for liabilities and taxes. IRS Publication 225 covers farm tax basics, though a business purchase calls for a professional's advice. Financing might come from a bank, the seller or farm loan programs, and farmers.gov loans and your local FSA office can tell you what's available. The SBA planning guide helps you build the plan.

Walk away if the numbers or the paperwork don't hold up. There's always another creamery, but there's only one of your savings.