How do I evaluate a dairy purchase?
Look past the price tag
LANCASTER, Pennsylvania — Evaluating a dairy for purchase means testing three things separately: the land and facilities, the herd and its records, and the business that sits on top of both. A price that looks fair on the land can hide a tired barn, a herd with health problems, or a milk contract that won't transfer. Treat the purchase like an inspection with a checklist, and bring in people who know more than you in each area.
Start with the milk market and the contract
Before anything else, find out who picks up the milk and whether that arrangement survives a sale. Some buyers or cooperatives have membership rules, base programs or hauling limits that don't automatically pass to a new owner. Ask the buyer in writing what a new owner would get. A dairy with a hauler and a market is worth far more than the same farm without one. Look at the milk checks, not just the summary the seller gives you, including components, premiums, deductions and quality results.
Inspect the land and the facilities
Walk every field with the soil survey in hand; the Web Soil Survey is free and shows soil types and limitations. Check drainage, slope and flood risk. Review the nutrient management plan and manure storage capacity, and ask whether the farm is in compliance with state rules. Look at wells and water supply for quantity and quality.
For buildings, ask for the age and condition of the parlor, tank, ventilation, flooring, feed storage and manure system. Bring someone who builds or repairs milking systems. Deferred maintenance is the quiet cost in most dairy sales, and it never shows up in a listing photo. Check the milking equipment's service history and whether it matches the herd size you plan to run.
Test the herd, not just count it
If the cows are part of the deal, ask for herd records: production, somatic cell counts, reproduction, culling reasons, mastitis history, calf and heifer survival, and vaccination and health test records. Your veterinarian should review them and, if possible, examine the herd. Ask about diseases your vet considers important for your region and whether the herd has been tested. Compare the heifer inventory to the cow herd, because a farm with no replacements is selling you next year's problem.
Run the numbers as your farm, not theirs
Re-do the seller's budget with your own labor, debt service, family living and feed costs. Include repairs you'll face in the first few years. Use a conservative milk price assumption and test a bad year. Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker and farmdoc daily have budgeting resources you can adapt.
Ask a lender early what they'd finance. A lender's appraisal and a seller's asking price often disagree, and it's better to learn that before you're deep into negotiation. For a first purchase, look at the FSA loan options and what they require.
Bring in the right people
Assemble a short team: an attorney who handles farm real estate, an accountant, a veterinarian, a milking-system technician, and your lender. Ask them to review before you commit, and build inspection and financing contingencies into the offer.
A last question worth asking: why is the farm for sale? Retirement, divorce, an environmental issue and plain burnout all lead to very different purchases. A farm can be a good deal and still be a bad deal for you, particularly if it needs skills or hours you don't have.