How do I know if a dairy farm is viable?

Cost of production against the milk check

BARABOO, Wisconsin — A dairy farm is viable if, over a stretch of years rather than one good or bad one, it earns enough to cover all its costs, pay its debts, pay the family a living wage, and replace worn equipment and animals. The honest way to find out is to calculate your cost of production per hundredweight of milk, compare it to your realistic milk price, and look at cash flow, debt and the trend in your own numbers. A single good month proves little, and a single bad one doesn't mean you're done.

The hard part isn't the math. It's using real numbers, including your own labor and family living costs, instead of optimistic ones.

Calculate your true cost of production

Add up every cost for a year: feed, purchased and home-raised, labor including unpaid family labor, vet and breeding, supplies, utilities, fuel, repairs, insurance, interest, depreciation, taxes and a reasonable return on your own management and equity. Divide by hundredweight of milk shipped. Don't forget heifer-raising costs and the value of crops you grow. Tools and worksheets are available from Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker, farmdoc daily and your state extension programs. The IRS Publication 225 covers farm tax records, which can be a good source for expense numbers.

Compare against milk price and margin

Look at the price you actually receive, not a headline price, after deductions and including components, premiums and hauling. Current prices and futures-based outlooks are available through USDA AMS market news, Dairy Markets and USDA ERS. Compare your cost to a range of possible prices, not just today's, and test how a few bad months would affect cash flow. Check what risk-management tools are available, including dairy margin coverage and other options, by asking FSA and RMA about current details.

Look at cash flow, debt and trends

Profit on paper doesn't pay bills if cash is tight. Build a monthly cash flow projection and see how much working capital you have. Check your debt-to-asset ratio, repayment capacity and how much of each milk check goes to debt service. Look at trends over several years: milk per cow, feed cost per hundredweight, somatic cell count, culling rate, pounds of milk per worker. If costs are creeping up faster than price, you want to know that early. A lender, FSA farm loan staff and your extension farm management specialist can help with analysis, often at no cost.

Compare with similar farms

Benchmarking against similar herds tells you where your costs or production are out of line. Many states and universities run dairy benchmarking programs; ask your extension office. Look at which costs are high: feed, labor, replacement or interest. Small changes in the biggest items usually matter most. Also ask whether your farm's location, market access, herd size and labor supply fit what the business needs. Some farms are viable at a modest size with low costs and strong marketing; others need scale. Neither is automatically right.

Decide what to do with the answer

If numbers show you're viable, keep tracking and invest in the areas with the best payback. If they're marginal, look for cost cuts, added value such as components, grazing, organic or direct marketing, or changes in herd size. If they're not viable, an earlier decision gives you more options. Talk with your lender, family, accountant and extension specialist. Some farms transition to other enterprises, rent out land or sell cows in an orderly way. Support is available, including Farm Aid and farmers.gov. Making the call with good numbers beats making it in a panic.

A short list to start:

  1. Calculate cost per hundredweight honestly.
  2. Compare against a realistic price range.
  3. Build a monthly cash flow.
  4. Benchmark against similar farms.
  5. Meet with your lender and an advisor.