How do I track creamery production costs?
Know the cost of every pound
LEXINGTON, Kentucky — Tracking production cost means knowing, for each cheese you sell, what it costs you to produce a pound of it. Without that number, you're setting prices by guesswork and hoping the bank balance tells you the truth later. The method isn't complicated, but it does need to be done consistently, batch by batch.
Start with the batch
Every make has inputs and outputs. Inputs: milk (volume and price), cultures, rennet, salt, other ingredients, packaging, labor hours, energy and water. Outputs: finished weight after trimming and, for aged cheese, after moisture loss. Record these for each batch on a make sheet. Cost per pound is total batch cost divided by saleable pounds.
Yield is the number that surprises people. Milk composition changes with season and feed, so the same recipe yields different weights at different times of year. Track yield for each batch so you can see the pattern.
Direct costs
Direct costs go straight into the cheese:
- Milk, whether from your own herd (at a fair internal price) or purchased.
- Cultures, rennet, salt and flavorings.
- Packaging and labels.
- Direct labor in the make room and aging room.
- Testing and lab fees tied to batches.
If you milk your own animals, don't treat milk as free. Put a value on it based on what you'd get selling it, or on the actual cost of feed, labor and herd care. Otherwise you'll hide the cost of the dairy side and make the creamery look better than it is. A farm financial adviser or the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker can help set that up.
Overhead and shared costs
Overhead includes utilities, refrigeration, rent or loan payments on the building, insurance, licenses, equipment depreciation, cleaning and admin time. Spread overhead across products in a logical way, such as by labor hour, by pounds produced or by share of aging space. The method matters less than using the same one over time and writing it down.
Don't forget costs that hide: shrink from cheese lost to trimming or spoilage, samples given away, returns and the time cost of delivery.
Aging adds its own cost
Aged cheese costs more than fresh even with the same milk. You're paying for aging space, refrigeration, flipping and washing labor, moisture loss and the cost of money tied up for months. Add an aging cost per month per pound and track it by cheese type. This is also why some aged styles need higher prices.
Use the numbers
Once you have cost per pound for each cheese, compare it to the price in each channel after fees. Cost tracking tells you which cheeses make money and which are charity. You may find your favorite cheese loses money, or a simple fresh product carries the plant. For help with cost analysis and marketing, see AgMRC and Farmdoc Daily. For taxes and recordkeeping, IRS Publication 225 covers farm income and expenses, and your preparer can advise on inventory methods.
Keep it going
Review costs monthly. When milk prices, packaging or wages change, update your numbers and your prices. A spreadsheet is enough, as long as you fill it in the same day you make the cheese. Costs you "remember later" usually come out lower than the real ones.
Common blind spots
A few costs get missed again and again. Cleaning chemicals and water for sanitation are real production costs. So are lab tests, pest control and license fees. Unsold product, trim and cheese that failed quality all belong in your cost per pound, spread across what you do sell. Time spent on deliveries and markets is labor too. If you pay yourself nothing, assign a wage anyway so your cost numbers reflect what a hired maker would cost. Compare your computed cost to your actual bank statements each quarter. If they disagree by a lot, something is missing from your sheet.