What affects component prices?
Butterfat, protein and other solids
ITHACA, New York — Component prices for butterfat, protein and other solids are driven by the wholesale prices of butter, cheese, nonfat dry milk and dry whey, the factors in the federal formula that convert those prices to component values, and the supply and demand for each product. The values move independently, which is why butterfat can climb while protein slips. Knowing which product feeds which component helps you see your milk check coming.
This article explains the link between products and components, the outside forces behind each, and where to find the current numbers.
Butterfat follows butter
Butterfat value comes mainly from the butter price, less a make allowance, converted by a yield factor. When butter demand is strong, from retail, bakery and restaurant use, or when cream is scarce, butterfat rises. When cream is plentiful, butter prices ease and so does butterfat.
Cream supply depends on milk volume and on how many plants separate cream for ice cream, cheese and butter. Seasonal demand matters too, since holiday baking can strengthen butter. Check the butter prices in the AMS dairy market news and the weekly product report from NASS.
Protein follows cheese and whey
Protein value comes from the cheese price and the dry whey price, with the formula crediting the protein that goes into cheese and the protein in whey. When cheese is strong, protein rises. Because whey protein has become valuable as an ingredient, strong whey markets can support protein value too.
Cheese demand depends on pizza, restaurant traffic, retail and exports. Cheese supply depends on plant capacity and how much milk is available. New plants can change regional supply and demand quickly. Exports also play a role, so watch trade conditions. The US Dairy Export Council shares industry perspective on exports.
Other solids follow dry whey
Other solids, mostly lactose and minerals, are priced from dry whey. This is the smallest piece of the milk check in most months, but it can swing. Dry whey is used in food manufacturing and animal feed, and exports matter a lot. When overseas buyers step up, the price tends to rise.
Because the other solids value is tied to a single product, it is more volatile than butterfat or protein in percentage terms. For background, the Economic Research Service publishes dairy market overviews.
The formula in the middle
Make allowances and yield factors, set in the federal order rules, sit between product prices and component prices. A change in those factors can change component prices even if the products don't move. They are updated through the federal order amendment process, so keep an eye on notices in the Federal Register.
Another piece is the price survey itself. If the share of product sold under contract versus spot changes, or the survey scope changes, component values can shift. I won't quote the current factors, since they're subject to revision.
Why components matter more now
Most milk is paid on components rather than on volume alone, so a hundredweight of high-test milk is worth more than a hundredweight of thin milk when butterfat and protein values are strong. Processors want solids because cheese yield depends on them. That shifts the question from how many pounds you ship to what is in those pounds, and it is why herd breeding and ration decisions show up in the check.
What you can control
You can't set component prices, but you can change what your cows produce. Breed, genetics, feed and herd management all change butterfat and protein tests. A farm with higher components gets more value per hundredweight when component prices are strong. Work with your nutritionist to evaluate rations for milk components, and check what your buyer pays for butterfat, protein and cell count.
Compare your components to the order average, which is published, and think about which one pays best for your milk in the current market. Farmdoc daily and extension dairy programs publish analysis on component economics.
Tracking checklist
- Watch weekly butter, cheese, nonfat dry milk and dry whey prices.
- Check announced butterfat, protein and other solids values each month.
- Compare your tests to the order average.
- Ask your nutritionist about ration changes aimed at components.
- Look at your handler's premiums for components and quality.
Component prices tell you what the market is paying for each piece of the milk. Once you can see which piece is strong, you can ask whether your herd is built to deliver it. And if a number doesn't make sense, check the source before blaming the cows.