What affects milk price formulas?
The pieces behind your milk check
MADISON, Wisconsin — Your milk check comes from a formula, and the formula depends on several inputs. In areas under Federal Milk Marketing Orders, USDA sets minimum prices that handlers must pay, calculated from the wholesale prices of dairy products like cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and whey. Your actual check also depends on your component levels, premiums, deductions and your cooperative or processor's own policies. Formulas have been changed over time by rulemaking, so check the current version rather than trusting an old explanation. This article describes the mechanics and tells you where to find the current details.
Classes of milk
Milk is classified by how it's used. Fluid milk is Class I, soft products like yogurt and ice cream are Class II, cheese is Class III, and butter and dry milk products are Class IV. Each class has a price formula. The blend of classes in your market determines the blend price paid to farmers in the marketing order. Because cheese uses a large share of milk in many regions, cheese and whey prices have a big effect, though regions and orders vary. Explore your order's pricing and class use at USDA AMS.
Product prices and make allowances
Wholesale prices for cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and dry whey are gathered in weekly USDA surveys. The formulas subtract make allowances, which approximate the cost of manufacturing, and use yield factors to convert product prices into milk component prices. These allowances and factors are set by rule and can be updated through the federal rulemaking process. Check the Federal Register and AMS dairy pages for current values and proposed changes. You can read and comment on rules through Regulations.gov.
Components and quality
Most milk is priced on butterfat, protein and other solids rather than just volume. A higher component test generally means more product from the same hundredweight, and your check may reflect that. Somatic cell count, bacteria and other quality measures can bring premiums or deductions, depending on your buyer. Look at your milk statement line by line. If you don't understand a deduction, ask your field representative to walk through it. That's a normal request, and a good one.
Pooling, deductions and cooperative policies
Federal orders pool revenue so that producers share in the value of different uses. Cooperatives may add premiums, charge hauling and membership fees, and set their own payment programs. Not all milk is under a federal order, and some states have their own systems. Your handler should be able to explain which applies to you. For market information, Dairy Markets and the U.S. Dairy site offer background, and university dairy economists often publish explainers.
Managing the variability
Milk prices move because product prices move. Tools like Dairy Revenue Protection, offered through USDA RMA, and the dairy margin programs through USDA FSA can help manage risk. Program rules, premiums and sign-up periods change, so check with the agencies or your local office for current details. Ask your cooperative about forward contracting options too.
Questions for your processor
- Which order or system prices my milk?
- Which components and quality measures affect my premiums?
- What deductions appear on my statement and why?
- What forward pricing options do you offer?
Reading your own statement
Pull out a recent milk statement and mark it up. Find the hundredweight shipped, the butterfat, protein and other solids tests, and the price for each component. Look for the lines showing premiums, such as quality or volume, and deductions, such as hauling, promotion or cooperative fees. Compare the components to your herd's usual range. If a component test dropped, think about feed, cow health and season. If a price component changed, compare it with the wholesale product price reports on the AMS site to see whether the movement matches. If something doesn't add up, ask your field representative or the market administrator's office for your order. They explain these formulas regularly. Keep a year of statements in a folder, since patterns show up over time that a single month hides.
Reading a milk statement can feel like reading a tax form, only the cows are less patient. Take it one line at a time, and ask for help with the lines you don't recognize.
