What are check-off fees?

Small deductions, national promotion

SIOUX FALLS, South Dakota — A check-off fee is a required deduction taken from the sale of an agricultural commodity and pooled to pay for promotion, research and producer education for that commodity. If you've ever looked at a milk check, a sale barn receipt or a grain settlement and wondered about a small line labeled something like "assessment" or "promotion," that's it. The money doesn't go to the government's general fund. It goes to a board or council set up under a federal research and promotion law, or under a state law that works the same way.

Check-offs get argued about at coffee shops more than almost anything except the price of diesel. Some farmers see them as cheap advertising that no single operation could afford alone. Others see a deduction they never voted on. Both views are common, and the useful thing is to know exactly how yours works.

How a check-off is set up

Each national program starts with a federal act passed by Congress for a specific commodity. The act authorizes USDA to issue an order, and the order spells out who pays, who collects, what the rate is, how the board is chosen and what the money can be spent on. The rate is written into the law or order, not decided by whoever happens to run the promotion board that year. Changing it generally takes an amendment to the order, and sometimes a vote of producers. Because rates can change, this article doesn't quote one. The current rate for your commodity is in the order itself, which you can find through the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service research and promotion pages, and in the notices posted at the Federal Register.

Who collects it and where it shows up

The deduction is usually taken at the first point of sale. For milk, that's the handler or cooperative that buys it. For cattle, it's the buyer or market. For grain, it depends on the commodity and the state. The buyer holds back the assessment and sends it on to the board or to a qualified state program. You'll often see it on the settlement sheet as a short line item. If you sell direct and the buyer is you, such as a farmstand or a custom-processed beef sale, the rules on who remits can differ, so don't assume you're exempt or covered. Ask the board.

Where the money goes

Check-off dollars pay for things like consumer advertising, new-use research, export market development, nutrition education and sometimes production research. Federal law generally bars these funds from being used to lobby or influence government policy, which is why you'll see separate membership organizations doing policy work. USDA oversees the boards, approves budgets and can review how funds were spent. Boards publish annual reports. If you want to know what your assessment bought, read the report rather than the billboard.

What you can actually do about it

Start by reading your settlement. Confirm the deduction matches the rate in the order for your commodity and your sales volume. If something looks off, call the buyer's accounting office first, then the board. Next, find out how your board members are chosen. Many are nominated from the producer pool and appointed by USDA, and openings are announced publicly. Serving on a board is the most direct way to change how the money is spent. Finally, ask whether a referendum process exists for your program. Most acts include a way for producers to petition for a vote on continuing the program, though the thresholds differ.

Questions worth asking your board

If you're skeptical, good. Ask the board these:

  1. What's the total collected last year, and what share went to each program area?
  2. How are projects evaluated, and are results published?
  3. How are board seats filled, and when's the next vacancy?
  4. Is any portion passed to a state or regional program, and how do I see that budget?

A decent board answers these without flinching. For general help reading an order, your state extension office or a university ag economist can walk you through it, and the National Agricultural Law Center publishes plain-language explainers on how these programs are built.

The fee is small on any single check. Whether it's a good deal depends on whether you've read what it buys.