What causes cheese to crack?

Dry rinds and fast pressing

BURLINGTON, Vermont — Cheese cracks for a handful of reasons, and most trace back to moisture, acid or pressure. A rind that dries too fast, curd that's too dry or too acidic, pressing too hard too early and big temperature swings all cause cracks. Some cracks are only skin deep. Others run through the wheel. Here's how to diagnose which problem you have and what to change, so the next wheel comes out of the cave in one piece.

Surface cracks from drying

If cracks appear in the rind, the air in your cave is probably too dry. Humidity under about 80 percent dries the surface faster than moisture can move from the center. The rind shrinks and splits, often in thin lines that follow the pattern of the mat or mold it sat on.

Raise humidity, wipe wheels with a light brine cloth, or wax or bandage the cheese. Reduce airflow if it's blowing straight on the wheels. A shallow tray of water or a damp towel in a closed aging box can lift humidity quickly. Check with a hygrometer rather than guessing, and check it daily for a week after any change.

Pressing problems

Heavy pressing too early can close the surface and trap whey inside. Later, the wheel shrinks and cracks. Follow the recipe's pressure schedule, usually light at first and heavier later, with the wheel flipped and re-dressed at set times.

Dry curd also cracks easily because it lacks elasticity. If your curd is cut too small, cooked too hot or cooked too long, the cheese turns brittle and the rind can split as it dries. Poor knitting between curd pieces leaves seams that open into cracks too. Keep curd warm and moist while you fill the mold, and don't let it cool and dry out on the table.

Acid and gas

Cheese that is too acidic can become crumbly and crack. If your culture is too active or acid develops too quickly, you may need to reduce culture, cool the vat or wash the curd. Cheese with very low moisture and high acid is the usual suspect when the paste crumbles when you cut it.

Gas from unwanted bacteria can also split wheels from inside. That's a sanitation or milk quality problem, not a cracking issue alone. Look for puffy wheels, strong off smells and many gas holes. Late-gas problems often point to contaminated milk or equipment, so review your cleaning and milking routines.

Temperature swings

Moving cheese from warm to cold rapidly can crack the rind. Cave temperature that swings widely stresses the wheel. Use a controller to keep temperature steady, and avoid leaving wheels on the counter while you do other chores.

In Swiss-type cheeses, rapid gas formation during warm room aging can crack wheels. Move them to cool storage when eyes develop. Wax that was applied to a cold, damp wheel can also crack and let air in, so dry the cheese and warm it to room temperature before waxing.

How to prevent it

Write down your pressing schedule, cook time, humidity and temperature. Change one variable at a time. Take pictures of cracks and note where they showed up, since the location tells you a lot: rind-only cracks point to drying, deep cracks near the center point to pressing or gas, and cracks along curd seams point to poor knitting.

Cracked wheels can still be safe to eat if they smell and look normal, but deep cracks can let bad mold in. Trim and use quickly if needed, and don't sell wheels you doubt. For more information, see Penn State Extension, eXtension, Cornell Small Farms and AgMRC.

Here's a quick checklist to run through when a wheel splits. First, look at where the crack sits and how deep it goes. Second, check your cave log for humidity and temperature changes in the days before. Third, review the make sheet for cut size, cook temperature and pressing weights. Fourth, smell the cheese for gas or off odors. Most cracks have a single main cause, and finding it is worth more than any recipe change you make blind.

A cracked wheel is a lesson with a rind on it. Grate it over something.