What cultures do beginner cheesemakers need?
Two cultures cover most first cheeses
BURLINGTON, Vermont — Most beginners need only two cultures: a mesophilic starter for soft and semi-hard cheeses, and a thermophilic starter for mozzarella and Swiss-style cheeses. Add a mold powder later when you try bloomy rind or blue cheeses. That's a short shopping list, and it covers a surprising amount of ground. Buy small packets, label them, and keep them cold.
What a starter culture does
A starter culture is a group of bacteria that eats the lactose in milk and produces lactic acid. That acid sets the stage for everything else: curd texture, flavor, how much whey leaves the curd, and which unwanted bacteria can't grow. Without it, you're relying on whatever bacteria show up, and the results are unpredictable.
Cultures come freeze-dried in direct-set packets, which you add straight to the milk, or as mother cultures you propagate yourself. Beginners should use direct-set packets. They're simple, consistent, and keep for a long time in the freezer if you follow the supplier's storage directions.
The mesophilic starter
Mesophilic means "middle temperature loving." These cultures work best around the temperatures used for cheddar, gouda, colby, chevre, and many farmhouse cheeses, roughly the mid-seventies to low nineties in Fahrenheit. A general-purpose mesophilic culture handles a wide range of recipes. Some blends include extra bacteria that produce small holes or buttery flavor, so read the packet description to match the cheese.
If you buy only one culture, make it a mesophilic type. It makes a good chevre, cottage cheese, queso blanco style cheeses with help from acid, and most hard cheeses.
The thermophilic starter
Thermophilic cultures prefer higher temperatures, often cooking temperatures in the range used for mozzarella, provolone, parmesan style cheese, and Swiss types. If your recipe says to heat the curd well above body temperature, it probably wants a thermophilic culture. Heat would kill a mesophilic culture, which is the reason the two aren't interchangeable.
For a deeper explanation of how the two differ, see the separate article in this series on mesophilic versus thermophilic cultures.
Other items you'll meet later
- Mold powders for bloomy rinds or blue veining, added after you're comfortable with basic cheeses.
- Lipase for sharper, piquant flavor in Italian styles.
- Calcium chloride to help a firm set in pasteurized or homogenized milk.
- Rennet, which is an enzyme and not a culture, but is on every beginner's list.
Don't buy ten products at once. Start with one culture and one rennet, make the recipe three times, and learn what changes.
Handling and storage
Follow the supplier's storage instructions closely. In general, keep freeze-dried cultures cold, keep moisture out, use clean dry measuring spoons, and don't contaminate the packet by dipping a wet spoon in. Check for expiration. A dead culture will look fine and do nothing, and you'll blame the milk.
Use the right dose. The packet will specify an amount per gallon or per batch. Less isn't thriftier, since underdosing slows acidification and invites trouble.
A sample starter kit
A practical beginner kit costs little. One packet of a general-purpose mesophilic culture, one packet of a thermophilic culture, a small bottle of liquid rennet, a small bottle of calcium chloride, and a few spare muslin cloths. That kit makes chevre-style cheese, farmhouse cheddar-style cheese, and mozzarella. If you want to try a bloomy rind later, add a mold powder and a small mat.
Direct-set or reusable
Direct-set packets are single-use. You open one, dose the milk, and re-seal the rest according to the supplier's instructions. Some packets are sized for a certain number of gallons, so check the label before you assume one packet equals one batch. Reusable mother cultures let you make your own from milk, but they demand more care and can drift or pick up contamination. Beginners should skip them until they have a dozen batches behind them.
Where to look for help
For general food safety and dairy basics, the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service and eXtension are reliable. The Cornell small farms program and Penn State Extension carry farmstead dairy resources. If you're planning to sell cheese, ask your state agency which cultures and processes it accepts. Culture suppliers usually include recipe guides with packet recommendations, and many have staff you can ask about matching a culture to a cheese.
A short culture list, kept cold and labeled, beats a drawer full of mystery packets.